The Trial of Battlefield 4 | PCGamesN

The Game Awards 2014 announces fan and jury nominees and categories

Chivalry isn't dead - Chivalry: Medieval Warfare is free for the weekend

EVE Online's "This is EVE" trailer uses player voice comms to capture the MMO

Battlefield 4

The Trial of Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4

Six months after its release for general sale, Battlefield 4 remains a bug-ridden, broken game. Despite repeated patches from DICE and EA, the moment one problem disappears another six seem to make an appearance. 

Fed up with Battlefield’s crimes, the FBI haul it into custody and place the game on trail. This is the thrilling courtroom drama that results from such arrest. 

The trail will be overseen by Judge Reinhold. Representing the players and purchasers of Battlefield 4 is District Attorney Ernest Arthur Suchs. Battlefield 4 has been assigned a Public Defender in the guise of PCGN writer Matt Purslow. You - the jury - have been sworn in, and the case is about to begin.

E.A Suchs: Your Honor, Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury, the defendant is charged with being an incompetent product. Its crimes are numerous: sound cut-outs, server crashes, queueing problems, and rubber banding. It even has the audacity to continue committing offences; only this week was the defendant discovered creating impenetrable barriers over dead player corpses. Simply put, Battlefield 4 is a fraudulent promise. It’s an incomplete game that has never worked, and probably never will. It should be locked away on a life-time sentence and all players should be given a full refund. 

M. Purslow: Your Honor, the Jury, Mr. Suchs is demanding punishments far and above the crime. I believe that despite its missteps, Battlefield 4 has been a valuable member of the gaming community. 

E.A. Suchs: Objection! How can you possibly have come to such a conclusion? By DICE’s own admission, the servers can’t even cope with the demands put on them

M. Purslow: It’s true that some servers have difficulties, but for the majority of my sixty hours with Battlefield 4 I’ve witnessed fewer performance issues than many reports would lead you to believe. Since launch I’ve almost exclusively played on 64-player maps, and found them to be chaos-promoting death arenas of the very best kind. Lets take a moment to look at Mr. Field’s best qualities, rather than daming him for a few marks on his permanent record. 

Battlefield 4 is a true team player. Never before in the history of the Battlefield family has there been a Battlefield this dedicated to playing as a close-knit team. Field Upgrades is a new feature, granting buffs and bonuses to players as rewards for good team play. Follow a squad command, resurrect a team-mate, repair a vehicle with a squaddie inside: all these actions build the Field Upgrades meter, resulting in better armour, more bullets, automatic repairs, or cloaking from radars. Genuinely useful and desirable abilities that bring squads together in order to achieve them. And Battlefield encourages people to stay together by deducting Field Upgrade points for letting your squad down. This is a game committed to bringing people together. Isn’t that an admirable quality, especially since its peers are forever promoting the egotistic self in the form of solo killstreaks?

E.A. Suchs: Objection! You're just assuming people will make use of such a feature. And I hardly think some good spirited community work can excuse it from a list of crimes as long as my leg.

(Court note: Mr. Suchs’ inside leg measurement is 32 inches)

Judge Reinhold: Objection overruled. Mr Purslow, could you please continue to clarify the defendant’s other redeeming features? 

Blue shells in Battlefield 4: that is the sort of rubber banding we want.

M. Purslow: Certainly your Honor. Battlefield 4 has offered players the most customisable soldier roles in the history of the series. Prior generations have pigeon-holed players into a handful of jobs, and whilst it is true that Battlefield 4 has only four class options, these roles have never been more versatile. Take the Recon role for example. Traditionally a sniper’s position, anyone who was unable to used a scoped rifle with precision was unable to advance this class to its highest rank. But Battlefield 4 allows multiple play styles in each class. Now you can play Recon as a close-combat, shotgun-wielding soldier from almost the very start of the game. You can assign it a Field Upgrade path that promotes stealth and enemy identification rather than tricky long-range kills. You can even act as a sneaky tank hunter with the class, thanks to unlockable C4. 

E.A. Suchs: Isn’t tank destruction the job of the Engineer?

M. Purslow: Traditionally yes. But now Recon and Support classes can use C4, they can act as the anti-ground units of a squad, freeing up the Engineer to be an anti-air unit. Helicopters continue to be one of the most vicious killing machines in the game, and now one member of a squad can be prepared for them at all times without sacrificing diversity. 

It also means that all classes can now cause massive amounts of demolition, which is pretty much what Battlefield is all about. There’s a great deal of destructible buildings around Battlefield 4’s huge maps, which crumble in the realistic fashion seen in Bad Company 2. This level of destruction was conspicuously absent in Battlefield 3. Indeed whilst many proclaim that Battlefield 4 is a shoddy update of Battlefield 3 instead of a true innovating sequel, I would suggest that Battlefield 4 is the complete product, and Battlefield 3 is the half-finished game missing the many features that the fourth title would eventually add. 

This game also thankfully does away with its predecessor’s horrendous upgrades path and replaces it with something logical. Unlocks are based on weapon types, so if you enjoy using assault rifles you need only to keep using them to unlock a new one. With weapons like carbines that can be used across multiple classes this allows quick progression without being forced to play a specific role. You can now decide what to work towards, rather than the game deciding for you. A true victory in player choice, surely? 

Your days of scratching skyboxes are over, tall building.

I’d also like to point out that Levelution - whilst a crime against the English language - is a real triumph for DICE. Take Flood Zone for instance; a map which transforms from tank-friendly streets to canals only passable by boat with the destruction of a dam. It rewrites the way the map must be utilised, forcing people to base jump between rooftops, and turning what were shortcuts just two minutes ago into shooting galleries. 

I suggest if you want to test out just how well these features have been implemented, go now to your internet browser and load up Battlelog. Choose a server and join. It really won’t be the impossibility countless news stories and forums would lead you to believe. And you’ll have fun. You can level a skyscraper and kill everyone inside it. You can destroy an M-COM station and for just a few moments be hailed as the hero of the server. You can fly a reconnaissance drone into the face of a killstreaking sniper and free your squad from being pinned down. All glorious moments. And yes, I can't deny that I’ve been disconnected from games, been killed numerous times thanks to lag, and played matches that lost sound for minutes at a time. Battlefield does need to answer for these crimes. But let us not damn it entirely, when at its heart it is genuinely one of the most entertaining, well designed shooters for a good few years. I believe the jury should find the defendant not guilty of incompetence, although a lesser sentence for flaws would be satisfactory. 

E.A. Suchs: A desperate defence. Battlefield 4 may be as well designed as you claim, but it is not well crafted. I think we should be pushing for the death penalty, clearly a life sentence is too lenient for a game that’s offered naught but empty promises since its birth. 

Judge Reinhold: Such decision is not yours to make, Mr. Suchs. The jury - the good readers of PCGamesN - must be the ones to determine Battlefield 4’s fate. 

Will the jury please raise their hands to their keyboards and type their decision into the comments box beneath this article.  

Login or Register
5
+5
-0
unwanted's picture
481

Is it too late to tell the rest of the jury that I've not played Battlefield 4? I'll just go with the majority.

2
+2
-0
Dog Pants's picture
999

Likewise. The series seems to have set off in a different direction since Battlefield 3, and it's one I don't really care for. I can't precisely put my finger on what it is, but Battlefield 3 put me off buying Battlefield 4.

3
+3
-0
avatar
3

It's a shame because 4 is a better game than 3 in terms of level design, balance and the unlock system.

2
+2
-0
Lunatitch's picture
89

I've stopped playing BF4 some time ago, there's certain issues - like the shoddy netcode/tickrate that DICE refuses to fix - this makes the game unplayable for me.

I've started playing games like Insurgency and it's nice to play games where the server has a 60+ tickrate, feels so much smoother and more responsive.

I doubt I'll ever pick up another DICE game as long as they're being smothered by EA.

2
+2
-0
Masq's picture
2

I gave up on BF4, and found myself back at Battlefield 3.

The overall game is just horrible, from horrible netcode, rubber banding, the horrible vehicle/infantry balance. And the 6000 new gadgets to troll through.

They should have just stuck with the Battlefield 3 model.

And That god awful orange kill cam,

2
+3
-1
Danger Zone's picture
64

What was the point of this?

Look, it doesn't matter how awesome a game is when you read the bullet points on the back of the box. Even if all of those awesome features are included, if the game is mess of bugs, glitches, errors and crashes it doesn't matter. There is no way... NO WAY... EA and DICE did not know this disaster was coming when they squatted down and dumped it all over retail last year. When the directive "Beat Call of Duty Ghosts to market" takes priority over "Release a reliable product with as few bugs as possible," you get BF4.

1
+2
-1
xNuke's picture
44

And they still beat Ghosts

1
+1
-0
rexevolution's picture
1

Typically I don't post on forums like these. However, this little dialogue so reminded me of Plato's discussion with several of his interlocutors I just couldn't resist.

Anyhow, I suppose I'll say my piece regarding Battlefield 4. The game itself looks good, it's obvious that it was the first line of "next gen" games, but overall I think that for the most part it has good foundations.

That being said, and because the primary function (for me) of this game is multi-player, actually playing the game is absolutely infuriating. I really don't think I have words to describe how disappointing it is to have a "Correctly Configured" network and a stable 50 down 5 up connection speed - which by the way maintains around 20 - 28 Ms latency - and to regularly be forced to spend my time in game pondering the different ways that the rubber band industry could be brought down.

There really isn't much else to say about it, online play is unplayable; therefore the game is unplayable.

Alienware - Game VictoriousTurtle Beach
AMD's Mantle API: how it works and why PC developers will adopt it

Battlefield 4

AMD's Mantle API: how it works and why PC developers will adopt it

Battlefield 4's Final Stand now being stood by premium players, trailered for the rest of us

Battlefield 4's Final Stand now being stood by premium players, trailered for the rest of us

Battlefield 4's war concludes with Final Stand on November 18th

Battlefield 4's war concludes with Final Stand on November 18th

Final Stand DLC will bring bows to Battlefield 4 with explosive and sniper bolts, say dataminers

Final Stand DLC will bring bows to Battlefield 4 with explosive and sniper bolts, say dataminers

DICE open up Battlefield 4 PC test servers to premium console players

DICE open up Battlefield 4 PC test servers to premium console players

Judge dismisses securities fraud suit against EA; executives were just being optimistic

Judge dismisses securities fraud suit against EA; executives were just being optimistic

Some things Battlefield 4 has taught me about war

Battlefield 4

Some things Battlefield 4 has taught me about war

Battlefield 4: Final Stand now available on Community Test Environment

Battlefield 4: Final Stand now available on Community Test Environment

DICE:

DICE: "we lost player trust" because of Battlefield 4 launch

The big, fat Battlefield 4 Premium Edition is only a fortnight away

The big, fat Battlefield 4 Premium Edition is only a fortnight away

Before the Fall Patch: long-awaited Battlefield 4 fixes due today on Origin

Before the Fall Patch: long-awaited Battlefield 4 fixes due today on Origin

Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4 "Autumn Patch" sheds all the bugs; further improves netcode

The Battlefield 4 launch is just another high profile cock up

Battlefield 4

The Battlefield 4 launch is just another high profile cock up

Battlefield 4: Final Stand evokes memories of Battlefield 2142

Battlefield 4: Final Stand evokes memories of Battlefield 2142

Battlefield 4's September patch to emulate Battlefield 3's soldier movement

Battlefield 4's September patch to emulate Battlefield 3's soldier movement

War is cheap in Battlefield 4: it's free for a week and on sale

War is cheap in Battlefield 4: it's free for a week and on sale

EA hire eBay exec as their new CTO to help improve their games

EA hire eBay exec as their new CTO to help improve their games "as live services"

Watch 30 seconds of Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth before its Premium launch tomorrow

Watch 30 seconds of Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth before its Premium launch tomorrow

Battlefield 4: Everything We Know

Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4: Everything We Know

Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth is definitely coming out on July 15th; no take backs this time

Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth is definitely coming out on July 15th; no take backs this time

Battlefield 4 PC patch sees off Battle Pickup exploit, debugs Commander mode on mobile

Battlefield 4 PC patch sees off Battle Pickup exploit, debugs Commander mode on mobile

DICE celebrated Independence Day with an explosive Battlefield 4 easter egg

DICE celebrated Independence Day with an explosive Battlefield 4 easter egg

Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth due out on July 15th according to EA Origin Twitter account gaffe

Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth due out on July 15th according to EA Origin Twitter account gaffe

Battlefield 4 patch will put an end to adamantium shield

Battlefield 4 patch will put an end to adamantium shield