Why Call of Duty's audience is collapsing on PC, and how Activision can fix it | PCGamesN

This War of Mine trailer shows the brutality of surviving

One Minute to Midnight lets you start a revolution for free

Hearthstone win trading results in permanent bans and tournament disqualification

Call of Duty®: Black Ops II

Why Call of Duty's audience is collapsing on PC, and how Activision can fix it

Call of Duty collapsing

Just look at this graph.

It shows how each new Call of Duty game has fewer people playing multiplayer than the last. Yes, Call of Duty: Ghosts did have 37,000 players online concurrently on release day, and that’s impressive, but the game before it, Black Ops II, had 64,000. Modern Warfare 3 before that had 86,000, and so on. Is there any wonder after you've read our Call of Duty: Ghosts review?

Activision can’t escape the fact that the popularity of their flagship series is in freefall on PC.

But it doesn’t have to be.

We should be clear on this, Call of Duty is still making Activision millions of dollars. Ghosts sold more than 15.4 million copies on PC and console. That’s a phenomenal number. On top of that will be DLC sales, too. Which, Activision are saying, have been big. 

But this isn’t about sales numbers, it’s about player numbers. The series is still solvent but it’s not growing. It’s dying. It’s just that it’s profitable while it’s doing it. 

Next to World of Warcraft, Call of Duty is one of the pillars supporting Activision. It’s not going to sink the company any time soon but Activision should be looking to reverse that trend, grow their numbers on PC.

call of duty advanced warfare activision sledgehammer games

"The yearly release of a new Call of Duty game with little support for mods and almost no competitive features built-in made people hold back from switching over,” Team Dignitas’ Piet Smet tells me. “This started after Call of Duty 2 due to the sudden switch to modern combat in Call of Duty 4 and every Call of Duty game after that made the playerbase split up even more.”

And without a playerbase you can’t have a thriving eSports scene.

What’s killing the Call of Duty community is the yearly release cycle. You know that, from release day, you have about 12 months with the multiplayer before most the players migrate to its successor. All the work you put into unlocking gear, all the maps you buy, all the prestige levels you gain are devalued because there aren’t enough people in the servers.

“Even today there are still a large amount of players on the PC version of CoD2, CoD4 and so on,” explains Smet. “If they would all switch over to the newest Call of Duty game then it would be a huge player base once again.”

In Advanced Warfare, Troy Baker plays Private Mitchell. Who really ought to be named Parts, lolol.

Plus, to meet that release schedule there are three separate studios all working on their own Call of Duty independently of one another. That system doesn’t encourage innovation or evolution but stagnation. Your game needs to fit the mould of the other two studios. You’ve three years to build a multiplayer component to your game that fits in with the other two games of that cycle. 

It also means that the experience a team gained building the multiplayer for one Call of Duty won’t be evident in the next game or the game after that, because those games are being created by someone else. 

And, even though there’s a collective stock of assets and code shared among the separate studios, building the basic multiplayer for each successive Call of Duty game takes time. When Infinity Ward started work on Ghosts they didn’t just pick up from where Treyarch left off with Black Ops II, iterating on the work that studio did - Ghosts’ development overlapped with Black Ops II’s so the team had spend time designing and building a multiplayer that was virtually identical to Treyarch’s.

It’s an inefficient system.

This might sound like an argument against a yearly release cycle. It’s not. A new singleplayer campaign every year is great, for both players and Activision’s wallet. But it is killing the multiplayer. The sooner the two are separated the better.

Call of Duty’s singleplayer and multiplayer have always been separate. Since the very first game they were booted up from separate executables. Singleplayer and multiplayer development’s even been handled by different teams on the same game: Ghosts’ Extinction mode was made by Neversoft while Infinity Ward worked on the core game; Raven Software made all the DLC for Black Ops II so Treyarch could start work on their next game.

Instead, Call of Duty multiplayer should be an ongoing service, like Dota, Guild Wars and Counter-Strike: Global Offensive. Just look at the growth we’re seeing in Counter-Strike: Global Offensive’s player numbers. Since Valve began supporting the game, releasing new maps and developing a community the numbers have only gone up.

CS:GO is the second most popular game on Steam. More than 145,000 players have played it today. Not one Call of Duty game makes it into the top ten.

However, if you look at the top 100 games being played on Steam, six Call of Duty games make the list. Their combined number of players totals more than 35,000. If there was a single multiplayer Call of Duty on Steam it would be the service’s ninth most played game, and that’s from six dwindling communities. If a single Call of Duty was being supported actively by Activision it would easily contend with CS:GO.

Think what it would mean: the hours you spend in the game, the gear and levels you unlock aren’t voided every year. Your friends and clan don’t get spread between multiple games because some of you can’t afford the latest release. There would be thousands more players on the same servers meaning there’s a greater variety of game types to play.

Activision could devote a single studio to solely work on developing and evolving that multiplayer service. It would mean the studio wouldn’t have to repeatedly build the same game over and over with slight alterations but could, instead, focus on designing new maps, weapons, attachments, player models, mechanics, graphical enhancements, bug fixes, and balances that all slot into the one game. 

Technically this game already exists. Activision Shanghai and Raven Software made Call of Duty: Online, a free-to-play game stocked with maps and player models taken from Call of Duty and Black Ops. But it’s only available in China.

It doesn’t need to be free-to-play either. A small subscription, like the $5/£3 a month originally charged for Call of Duty: Elite Premium, over a year would add up to the equivalent of a single purchase of a new Call of Duty game. But the difference is that you’re not willingly buying a game that undoes your unlocks, splits up your friends, and harms the community.

Activision have poured money into Call of Duty for more than a decade, making one of the most finely polished shooters available, but unless they change how they deliver it to us on PC then it’s all going to waste.

Login or Register
4
+4
-0
Myrdraal's picture
8

Ppl don't buy CoD on PC because we have other less expensive FPS choices that are often quite better than this stale, beaten dead horse.

2
+2
-0
TsunamiWombat's picture
122

No offense - and I myself hate that this is a thing - but what makes you think they care about PC? They do gangbusters on Consoles. PC isn't the target market. Should it be? Absolutely, because it's huge. But there it is.

Every game makes more money than the last. Is it stupid, is it a bubble bound to burst? Are they bound to nickle, dime, and milk it to death? Absolutely. But they'll make billions in the process, so what do they care?

1
+1
-0
Ninjilla's picture
5

Actually, the bubble started bursting awhile ago. Sales for BO2 were less than MW3 after a certain time period (I think the first month) and Ghosts less than BO2. There's a lot more ways that Activision could be supporting COD for PC, and they should really capitalize on it after the letdown PC-support wise of Titanfall.

2
+2
-0
somebody336's picture
15

I would buy them if the Infinity Ward ports were better and they would give a bigger discount for the older titles. I mean come on, COD1 is still 20 bucks on Steam :/

2
+2
-0
хот dоg's picture
2

good article, and very true.,pc will rise again as consoles are now becoming an addition of luxury to the living room. But what you are confirming in the article is very sad.,

2
+2
-0
DeadlyFred's picture
3

The first and most important thing they need to do is get developers who give a crap about PC development and recognize that its not the same platform as a console. Treyarch is the only one doing this. MW3 and Ghosts were both god-awful PC games with bad, fixed FOV and sketchy mouse performance, amongst other technical bugs.

Fix that THEN worry about anything else because if you can't even make a PC game, no one on PC is going to play it anyhow.

1
+1
-0
yuurei's picture
6

People don't buy the new Call of Duty for the single player. I'm not saying what you're proposing is wrong or even unprofitable, but Activision would lose a lot of money on their yearly sales. How many % people do you think would buy the single player game? 30%? 20%? Who knows. I don't think the number would be very high.

Again, I'm not saying that a CS:GO or DotA 2 system is worse, in fact I think it's better and it would probably benefit Activision in the long run, but I don't think that Activision is capable of making such a major change.

And as a side-note, I really wouldn't mind of CoD died off. It's the same game released every year that teenagers everywhere beg their parents to buy them. There'd be more room for better games. Just my opinion.

1
+1
-0
Dog Pants's picture
969

The audience might be decreasing, but those spikes from new games are far higher than sales of the old ones. The graph shows players though, not sales. Once the game is bought it's effectively cutting into profit the longer it gets played, from ongoing costs like servers and support. Of course if people know they're only going to play the game for a few months then they might not buy it in the first place.

1
+1
-0
Maverickiv's picture
1

Standby for Titanfall!

Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
The best of the Steam Halloween Sale

Steam

The best of the Steam Halloween Sale

The Swindle is Spelunky meets Deus Ex, a stealth roguelike in a steampunk top hat

The Swindle

The Swindle is Spelunky meets Deus Ex, a stealth roguelike in a steampunk top hat

The 10 best World War 2 PC games

War Thunder

The 10 best World War 2 PC games

Enforcer: Police Crime Action is a full-blooded police simulator. Yet it’s hilarious

Enforcer: Police Crime Action

Enforcer: Police Crime Action is a full-blooded police simulator. Yet it’s hilarious

Beginner's guide to X-Wing and TIE Fighter: joystick issues, controls, and picking a version

X-Wing

Beginner's guide to X-Wing and TIE Fighter: joystick issues, controls, and picking a version

Inside Icewind Dale: Enhanced Edition and the future of D&D RPGs

Icewind Dale: Enhanced Edition

Inside Icewind Dale: Enhanced Edition and the future of D&D RPGs

Hands on with Dirty Bomb

Dirty Bomb

Hands on with Dirty Bomb

Topic of the Week: Do you buy season passes?

Topic of the Week

Topic of the Week: Do you buy season passes?

Dear everyone: it's time to stop buying season passes at launch

Season Pass

Dear everyone: it's time to stop buying season passes at launch

Making it in Unreal: How Yager are reinventing the open world in Dead Island 2

Dead Island 2

Making it in Unreal: How Yager are reinventing the open world in Dead Island 2

Guild Wars 2: Tyria prepares for war with the return of the Living World Season 2

Guild Wars 2

Guild Wars 2: Tyria prepares for war with the return of the Living World Season 2

Stockholm Syndrome: Why Scandinavia loves DreamHack

Hearthstone: Heroes of Warcraft

Stockholm Syndrome: Why Scandinavia loves DreamHack

Civilization: Beyond Earth review

Civilization: Beyond Earth

Civilization: Beyond Earth review

Warframe Archwing update turns you into a rocket-powered space ninja

Warframe

Warframe Archwing update turns you into a rocket-powered space ninja

Win a ticket to the Tank Museum and a premium Fury Sherman with World of Tanks

World of Tanks

Win a ticket to the Tank Museum and a premium Fury Sherman with World of Tanks

Lords of the Fallen is a ferocious, and infuriating Dark Souls clone

Lords of the Fallen

Lords of the Fallen is a ferocious, and infuriating Dark Souls clone

Red:Out is Wipeout, but on the PC. It’s about time.

Red:Out

Red:Out is Wipeout, but on the PC. It’s about time.

World of Warcraft: Warlords of Draenor gear guide: getting started

World of Warcraft: Warlords of Draenor

World of Warcraft: Warlords of Draenor gear guide: getting started

Putting on the deerstalker and becoming Sherlock Holmes in Crimes and Punishments

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

Putting on the deerstalker and becoming Sherlock Holmes in Crimes and Punishments

Topic of the Week: What games are you looking forward to in 2015?

Topic of the Week

Topic of the Week: What games are you looking forward to in 2015?

Rodina is No Man's Sky on a budget

Rodina

Rodina is No Man's Sky on a budget

Fighting the inevitable in Stardock's Sorcerer King

Sorcerer King™

Fighting the inevitable in Stardock's Sorcerer King

Paranautical Activity un-launches on Steam after creator threatens to kill Gabe Newell

Paranautical Activity

Paranautical Activity un-launches on Steam after creator threatens to kill Gabe Newell

The 100 Best Free PC Games

100 best free PC games

The 100 Best Free PC Games

Dear Microsoft: about that Minecraft deal

Minecraft

Dear Microsoft: about that Minecraft deal

Here's what's coming in EVE Online's Phoebe expansion, and beyond

EVE Online

Here's what's coming in EVE Online's Phoebe expansion, and beyond

Playing With Myself: Legend of Grimrock 2

Legend of Grimrock 2

Playing With Myself: Legend of Grimrock 2

Company of Heroes 2: Ardennes Assault is the single-player campaign you've been waiting for

Company of Heroes 2 - Ardennes Assault

Company of Heroes 2: Ardennes Assault is the single-player campaign you've been waiting for

Make conversation, not war: Galactic Civilizations III gets diplomacy

Galactic Civilizations® III

Make conversation, not war: Galactic Civilizations III gets diplomacy

World of Warcraft's handsome new character models in action

World of Warcraft: Warlords of Draenor

World of Warcraft's handsome new character models in action

The best PC games of 2014 so far

Best PC Games of 2014

The best PC games of 2014 so far

Topic of the Week: When getting a new PC, do you build or buy?

Topic of the Week

Topic of the Week: When getting a new PC, do you build or buy?

Port Inspection - The Evil Within

The Evil Within

Port Inspection - The Evil Within

Hands on with Assetto Corsa, a racing simulator made using lasers

Assetto Corsa

Hands on with Assetto Corsa, a racing simulator made using lasers

Assassin's Creed Unity

"Cinematic experience" is a nonsense term and isn't achieved by frame rates

Playing With Myself: Sid Meier's Covert Action

Sid Meier's Covert Action (Classic)

Playing With Myself: Sid Meier's Covert Action

Nvidia's plans to become a

Nvidia

Nvidia's plans to become a "full-service" video performance company

We've got 50 codes for Anno Online starter packs that'll make privateers of you

Anno Online

We've got 50 codes for Anno Online starter packs that'll make privateers of you

Wild Cards: what does the future hold for Hearthstone's fresh pros?

Hearthstone: Heroes of Warcraft

Wild Cards: what does the future hold for Hearthstone's fresh pros?

Total War: Rome II - One Year On

Total War™: ROME II - Emperor Edition

Total War: Rome II - One Year On