The Middle-Earth Roleplaying Project resists cease and desist letter

Comment

Following a cease and desist letter from Warner Brothers, the makers of the Middle-Earth Roleplaying project, a Skyrim mod, have begun a petition to have the decision revoked, allowing the developers to continue work on the Tolkein-inspired project.

MERP's an ambitious mod, aiming to recreate the entire storyline of Frodo's walk to Mordor in the Skyrim engine. That includes all the locations, characters, and quest lines necessary to faithfully capture the plot of the books. Development was still in early stages, with the Middle-Earth height map in place but not a great deal more, though that height map was nine times the size of the vanilla Skyrim install. Though the team planned on working till they'd created something with "a quality greater than that in vanilla Skyrim."

It may sound like a project destined for the "Too big to complete bucket" but it's been in development since 2008. The recent work has been porting it to Skyrim. Not building it from scratch.

All was going well until the team received a cease and desist letter from Warner Brothers, who currently own the rights for Lord of the Rings games. All work on the mod halted, but only long enough for them to contact a lawyer and start a petition. According to their Moddb page, currently they "have a lawyer from the Organisation for Transformative Works (OTW) on our side, currently aiding us in our appeal for being a transformative piece."

A transformative piece is when "the artist creates something exemplary differential from the original piece so much so that it can be called his own," or so says Illinois' Business Law Journal.

Whilst their lawyer is hard at work lawyering fans of the project aren't left entirely helpless, they can sign up to the "Save MERP from corporate greed!" petition, which currently has over 3,000 signatures.

Cheers, PC Gamer.

Login to comment

Enter your PCGamesN username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
Forgotten your password?

Elders Scrolls Online video shows “you can compete with friends to catch the biggest fish”

Fishing competitions and delicious creations in latest Elder Scrolls Online developer video

Elder Scrolls Online video takes you to Oblivion for a tour of Coldharbour

Skyrim: Legendary Edition now totally official and bound for June 7 release

Skyrim: Legendary Edition spotted in Poland

This Skyrim mod brings the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles to Tamriel

The Elder Scrolls Online monster showcase: S’Ogrim up north

Skyrim soundtrack beats Beethoven in Classic FM poll

Skyrim patch 1.9 is out, “effectively removes the overall level cap” via Legendary skill grind

Legendary composer Jeremy Soule kickstarts his first symphony

For the Dovahkeen: Skyrim Dragonborn statue pre-orders now open

Tropical Skyrim throws out climactic dragon fights for climate change

Elder Scrolls Online combat detailed; tanks not necessary, apparently

Skyrim 1.9 update “effectively removes the level cap”, adds legendary difficulty. Beta now on Steam

The Elder Scrolls Online beta invites coming this month

The Elder Scrolls Online won’t model hands or weapons in first-person