Red Orchestra 2 will be free forever on Steam - so long as you click the button today

Hazard Ops closed beta sign-up begins ahead of third-person pulverising in May

Mojang's Minecraft 1.8 world generator heralds "the return of floating islands"

Monaco developer Adam Schatz "stretch goals are total bullshit"

In a great interview over on Penny Arcade, Adam Schatz, the developer of the excellent looking top-down heist game Monaco, has related his thoughts on crowd-funding, Kickstarter in particular. Among other things he describes stretch goals as "bullshit". Does a pretty convincing job of it, too.

The kernel of his argument is that stretch goals, where a developer agrees to include new features with a game if they reach a certain funding target (new characters, vehicles, six more graphics, etc), forms a kind of additive design mentality. Suggesting that game design is about developing a basic game and then slotting in features. He says that "the way you should do it is you figure out what the game is, you figure out what the game needs, and you should make that.” He concedes there are other design methodologies but that's his core point.

It's an interesting argument. Certainly, games like Super Hexagon would lose something with addition. It's a perfectly honed game, one which gains from being so lean. Had backers (it wasn't a Kickstarter game, but if it where, hypothetically) asked for more levels, custom soundtracks, in-game speed options, well, it would have lost something.

"To me, you should decide if the game is incomplete without those features" Schatz says. "If the game is missing a finger, add a finger, if the game is not missing a finger, don’t add one. That’s sort of my take on Kickstarters."

Stretch goals bloat games.

This all said, and taking Schatz's concession into account, perhaps a way of looking at stretch goals is fast-tracking expansions/DLC. Publishers commission expansions for games which have proven their success. Stretch goals are a way of commissioning new features for Kickstarters that have proven their success. It's rolling the post-release stage of a game's sales into its development. Now, I don't think this is necessarily a good thing - as Schatz makes clear, it can muddle the vision of the the core game - but it does give us an appropriate model to view it with.

The main issue with stretch goals when compared to expansions is that expansions are released for successful games, more importantly  for released games. Money is never a good indicator of quality but sales are at least a sometime-symptom of it and retail success coupled with investors who can play the game they're commissioning to be expanded can at least deem the worth of the game for themselves, and sense whether there is a need for the features that are being proposed. The material with which the pledgers decide to commission, because they are commissioning, is often not going to be demonstrative of the quality of the final game.

It could be that backers throwing more money, more development time, and more features at a game that will not benefit from it in the slightest.,

Login or Register

Indie

Enemy Starfighter — At the crossroads of Homeworld, Myth, and TIE Fighter

Prisonscape will have you shanking your first gang leader in no time

Littlewargame is a multiplayer RTS that runs entirely in your browser

Epigenesis gains single player and new map

InSynch is a gorgeous stop-motion animated music game out on 24 April

Indie

Never leave a Broforce bro behind

Garry’s Mod virus filled servers with sound of coughing

Here Be Dragons has you hunt down the monsters of the sea for Queen and country

Starbound updates slowed while team moved to UK

JetGetters' Kickstarter cancelled as developer finds investor

Indie

FTL: Advanced Edition transforms the spacefaring rogue-like into a mind control space circus

Vlambeer is selling Nuclear Throne via Twitch and thinks you should buy it there

Spelunky world record broken once again - record breaker plans on topping it

Don't lose your towel: Grail to the Thief is an adventure game for the blind inspired by Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy

Indie

This way lies madness: Gaslamp Games and Clockwork Empires

Why X-COM creator Julian Gollop left handheld gaming behind and came back to the PC

Subnautica screenshots rise up out of the depths

Open season: Sir, You Are Being Hunted hits v1.0 on May 1st