Warlock 2: The Exiled review

This way lies madness: Gaslamp Games and Clockwork Empires

The Elder Scrolls Online review

Riot restrict streaming for League of Legends pro players, ban certain games outright

Riot places restrictions on LCS pro streaming

"Wait, no more Dyrus Hearthstone?!"

Yesterday, eSports-focused editorial site OnGamers broke the news that in the contracts for the 2014 season of LCS, pro players will have certain restrictions on what they are allowed to stream. Unsurprisingly, Riot don’t want their top pros to be streaming (and effectively advertising) other MOBAs on their public streams... but neither do they want them playing Hearthstone, Diablo, or World of Anything At All.

It’s a contentious point, because until now, LCS pros had been able to stream whatever they pleased and Hearthstone has become kind of the unofficial “off-hours eSport” for the entire competitive gaming world. Furthermore, stream revenue is an important source of income for many players and teams, and fans enjoy tuning in to see the pros casual gaming pursuits as much as their practice.

On the other hand, LCS pros are basically paid by Riot, now. League of Legends eSports is an extension of Riot and subject to both unprecedented investment and opportunity, and also unprecedented oversight.

Riot’s eSports director Whalen Rozelle remarked on Reddit, “...These guys are professionals contracted to a professional sports league. When they’re streaming to 50,000 fans, they’re also representing the sport itself. I can’t stress enough how these guys in the LCS are on the road to being real, legitimate athletes. This is new territory for a lot of teams (especially in esports), because the transition goes from being a group of talented individuals to being real icons of a sport and a league. Similarly, you probably wouldn’t see an NFL player promoting Arena Football or a Nike-sponsored player wearing Reebok on camera. Pro players are free to play whatever games they want – we’re simply asking them to keep in mind that, on-stream, they’re the face of competitive League of Legends.”

This is a bit self-serving, of course. Pro players sign sponsorship deals independent of their leagues and teams as a way of augmenting their salaries. For most Western pro players, streaming fills that role, and part of streaming is being able to build and hold the attention of a large audience. Diversity helps with that.

The other thing that makes this restriction seem a bit heavy-handed is that it goes beyond what most players and fans will see as Riot’s legitimate interests. Nobody would bat an eye at a contract that says, “You can’t stream Dota 2.” It’s preposterous to think that Riot would want to be paying a player a salary, and then have that player basically start promoting a rival. But Diablo, Hearthstone, World of Tanks, and Fat Princess (I mean, really?) do not seem like games that should be of much concern to the makers of the most popular MOBA in the world.

Which makes sense from a certain point of view, but perhaps not from Riot’s. The free-to-play economy is about engagement and time. If you look at this list, the common thread is that Riot don’t want their players streaming big time-sinks. Even if a game isn’t necessarily directly competitive with League of Legends in terms of genre or even business model, they can still be rivals for time and attention. And MOBAs thrive on consuming both, because the money tends to follow.

It’s also worth noting the unusual position that League of Legends pros find themselves in. Grassroots League of Legends doesn’t really exist, and there are no strong independent leagues where they can take their talents. The smaller tournament circuit has been subsumed by the LCS Challenger series.

This couldn’t really happen in StarCraft or Dota because neither Blizzard nor Valve exert such blanket control over the eSports ecosystem. But the deal that Riot offered was to make eSports more stable and lucrative for a larger number of players than any other eSport in the world. There are sixteen pro teams in North America and Europe comprised of five players apiece, with alternates and support staff. That’s a product of Riot’s investment. But the flip side is that the entire pro scene now has a boss named Riot, and the boss’s priorities have to become theirs.

Login or Register
Shriven's picture

Riot need to be taken down a peg. Who do they think they are? An actual respected sports organisational body?

unwanted's picture

These guys are professionals contracted to a professional sports league

Arrrrrghh!! *punches wall*

League of Legends

Riot Games manager talks the "hard realities" of working full-time on League of Legends

Riot have deployed "more human-like" bots in League of Legends - but they still can't jungle

League of Legends pro fined over "one of the highest harassment scores" in LCS history

Snow Leopard is feeding: Riot bump up minimum specs for League of Legends on Mac

Even esports had a montage: watch the Katowice 2014 highlights

Riot rejig League of Legends champion Twitch: they've had their sights set on him "for years"

League of Legends

League of Legends Champion Review: Vel'Koz, the Eye of the Void

League of Legends gets a new mode for a week, making everyone a death-dealing god

Everybody wants to be a Captain: Riot take action to quicken League of Legends Team Builder queues

Uncharted game director leaves Naughty Dog for "really innovative stuff" at Riot Games

Riot pull Night Hunter Rengar skin from League of Legends test servers, refund players

Riot believe Team Builder helps League of Legends players uncover their "inherent" good


As progaming team Quantic implode, a new installment of a sadly common eSports story

League of Legends' Team Builder is live in North America; lead developer responds to feedback

Weekend in Paris: Riot bring Europe "a little love" with League of Legends All-Star 2014

Riot roll out beta Team Builder for League of Legends, lay foundations for "great teamwork"

League of Legends 4.3 brings minor tweaks and teases Vel'Koz

The eye to avoid: Riot cast their champion spotlight over Vel'Koz

League of Legends

League of Legends Champion Review: Yasuo, the Unforgiven

Riot apologise for League of Legends disconnections, lag and login queues as arms race against hackers "continues to grow"

Blizzard rumoured to be modelling Heroes of the Storm's free-to-play on LoL

Super Hexakill: League of Legends gains six-player mode on February 20

Meet Vel'Koz, League of Legends' grotesque new champion

League of Legends 4.2 brings some nerfs and reworks, and winter skins make a return