Cliff Harris on Gratuitous Space Battles 2: it's a "whole new world"

Aerna creators claim it's the largest and most detailed Minecraft server

Come in from the cold: Linux compatible games are all the rage at GOG.com

Red Orchestra 2: Heroes of Stalingrad

Refighting the war in the Pacific in Rising Storm

Red Orchestra 2: Rising Storm faces an interesting problem: how do you make a balanced, historically accurate team-based multiplayer shooter out of the Pacific theater, where the defining feature of the land battles was their complete imbalance?

I spent an hour at GDC playing around with some of new American weapons and watching producer Tony Gillham playing the Japanese side. I was struck both by how cleverly Tripwire’s Rising Storm team are adapting features of the Pacific war into novel game mechanics, and the drastically asymmetrical tactics those mechanics impart to the game. I have my doubts that Rising Storm can be effectively balanced, but having seen it in action, that seems like a good thing.

While Japan went to war against the United States with a first-rate navy, its army much more closely resembled something from World War I than the mechanized land forces of Europe and United States. It was a bolt-action rifle and bayonet infantry force, with limited machine gun support, poor-quality submachine guns, and no rapid-fire rifles like the American M1 and BAR. Japanese troops were routinely at a huge firepower disadvantage, particularly toward the end of the war.

All of which makes for interesting military history, but not necessarily a great team FPS. Even in the early days of Red Orchestra 2, there was some grumbling from players who found themselves on the Soviet side of matches, who felt German small-arms tended to be a bit better and tilted the balance of matches their way. That was a war between two fairly equal opponents, so how can Rising Storm make a good game out of a contest between bolt-action rifles versus semi-automatics?

Don’t discount those bolt-actions too hastily, warned Gillham. “If I’m going to fight a bolt-action, I actually quite like to fire the Type 38 Japanese rifle. Personally, that’s a real favorite. Not too much kick, not too much recoil. You can fire off a round and pretty much zoom right back in again.”

The other part of the answer lies in playing up Japan’s particular strengths and favored tactics. While the Japanese may not have enjoyed much in the way of firepower, they did make use of grenade launchers. In Rising Storm 2, Japanese squads will usually have a couple grenade launchers to go around, capable of being used as direct-fire weapons or pointed skyward for use as an improvised mortar. The Japanese Type 99 grenade, meanwhile, had an unusual fuse design that allowed it to be used as a booby trap. Players will be able to set their grenades on the ground and wait for an American to run over it, or sit nearby and shoot it, making it a sort of IED.

The main weapon in the Japanese players’ arsenal, however, is the banzai charge. While the banzai charge was a disaster for the Japanese army during the war (by the end of the war, Japanese commander were throwing away thousands of Japanese lives in human-wave attacks against fixed positions), in Rising Storm is occupies an interesting tactical niche. In keeping with the reputation Japanese troops developed for fearlessness (under normal circumstances, the Japanese players are slightly less affected by suppression), and the unnerving effect the banzai charge had on its enemies, a Japanese officer can activate a banzai charge ability and grant suppression and fatigue resistance to his team and increase the suppression on American players, making them less accurate in combat.

“The Japanese are intrinsically less-suppressed,” said Gillham. “Not much. Just enough to make a difference. When you couple that with things like the banzai mechanic, where he’s really not suppressed, and the American guy is basically crapping himself, then that really redresses that balance.”

The catch is that the banzai charge is just that: a charge. You can’t activate it like a buff spell, you actually need an officer running at the head of his troops with katana drawn, screaming his lungs out as they advance against the enemy.

It’s not an easy way to fight. I watched the developer get cut down a few times before he finally made it inside American lines and started carving up GIs. In fact, everything about the Japanese side of the game seems to take a bit more skill and coordination. Even allowing for the fact that the US Marines Corps was under-equipped in the early stages of the war, it doesn’t seem like the Japanese side will fare well in battles between two equally skilled teams.

The Americans have a new tool of their own, the flamethrower, which was quite a lot of fun to use. But perhaps the main thing working to keep the game balanced is the harsh-terrain of the Pacific theater. From the the American perimeter at Guadalcanal at night to the black sands of the Iwo Jima beachhead, Rising Storm features some challenging battlefields that will give Japanese players a chance to negate the US fire-power advantage.

It may also require some careful objective placement and scenario design. In many ways Rising Storm reminds me more of a wargame than a military shooter, and it confronts many of the same problems that bedevil wargame design. In any remotely realistic simulation, the Japanese forces should lose the majority of their land battles against the United States, just like the Soviets should get slaughtered during the opening phases of Barbarossa and the Germans don’t have a snowball’s chance in hell of achieving victory in the Battle of the Bulge. Much of warfare, with a handful of famous exceptions, consists of bloody grinding toward a foregone conclusion.

Where things get interesting is in the “can you do better?” department. The Germans will lose, but can they achieve success by holding on a little longer. The Japanese may not be able to drive the Americans off Iwo Jima, but they can make the price a bit higher, and hold key objectives a little longer. Much of wargame design is making unfair fights into interesting contests of skill. To succeed, Rising Storm will need to do the same thing. Because far more than Stalingrad, Rising Storm is a game about the unfairest of fights.

Login or Register
Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
Cliff Harris on Gratuitous Space Battles 2: it's a

Gratuitous Space Battles 2

Cliff Harris on Gratuitous Space Battles 2: it's a "whole new world"

Aerna creators claim it's the largest and most detailed Minecraft server thumnnail

Aerna creators claim it's the largest and most detailed Minecraft server

Come in from the cold: Linux compatible games are all the rage at GOG.com thumnnail

Come in from the cold: Linux compatible games are all the rage at GOG.com

A British MP asked for in-game theft to be treated like real-world theft thumnnail

A British MP asked for in-game theft to be treated like real-world theft

Obsidian hope Pillars of Eternity sales will fund its sequel without Kickstarter thumnnail

Obsidian hope Pillars of Eternity sales will fund its sequel without Kickstarter

Respawn to introduce in-game 'black market' currency to Titanfall in Game Update 5 thumnnail

Respawn to introduce in-game 'black market' currency to Titanfall in Game Update 5

The Last Express: Jordan Mechner remembers a different sort of war game on the centenary of its departure thumbmail

The Last Express Gold Edition

The Last Express: Jordan Mechner remembers a different sort of war game on the centenary of its departure

The Sims 2 is now free on Origin, swimming pools and 18 expansions included thumnnail

The Sims 2 is now free on Origin, swimming pools and 18 expansions included

Star Wars: The Old Republic preps for largest story expansion since Rise of the Hutt Cartel thumnnail

Star Wars: The Old Republic preps for largest story expansion since Rise of the Hutt Cartel

Chat restrictions increase win rates for a

Chat restrictions increase win rates for a "large number" of League of Legends players

Well-thumbed: the Steam Controller has grown an analog stick thumnnail

Well-thumbed: the Steam Controller has grown an analog stick

Meet IL-2: Battle of Stalingrad —the high flying return of the PC's best combat flight-sim thumbmail

IL-2: Battle of Stalingrad

Meet IL-2: Battle of Stalingrad —the high flying return of the PC's best combat flight-sim

Cliff Bleszinski's Project BlueStreak snatches up AAA shooter designers and staff thumnnail

Cliff Bleszinski's Project BlueStreak snatches up AAA shooter designers and staff

Tim Schafer on Double Fine publishing and not being told what to do thumnnail

Tim Schafer on Double Fine publishing and not being told what to do

Get back in The Room when it comes to PC on July 28th thumnnail

Get back in The Room when it comes to PC on July 28th

The Humble Square Enix Bundle throws Hitman, Thief and even Anachronox at you thumnnail

The Humble Square Enix Bundle throws Hitman, Thief and even Anachronox at you

God Squad: Lara Croft and the Temple of Osiris due out in December thumnnail

God Squad: Lara Croft and the Temple of Osiris due out in December

The nine best Kerbal Space Program mods  thumbmail

Kerbal Space Program

The nine best Kerbal Space Program mods

The Walking Dead Season 2: Amid the Ruins PC review thumnnail

The Walking Dead Season 2: Amid the Ruins PC review

TrainFever’s simulations have me hot under the collar thumnnail

TrainFever’s simulations have me hot under the collar

Down but not out: West Games attempts to get funding for Areal after Kickstarter suspension thumnnail

Down but not out: West Games attempts to get funding for Areal after Kickstarter suspension

Wildstar Sabotage update adds 30 player PvP battleground thumnnail

Wildstar Sabotage update adds 30 player PvP battleground

Gods will be Watching trailer shows thrilling point’n’clicking thumnnail

Gods will be Watching trailer shows thrilling point’n’clicking