John Smedley on DayZ and H1Z1 similarities: “this is our take on the Zombie Apocalypse”

Splinter Cell: Echoes comics due this summer

Easter of the Vikings

EA doesn’t expect Star Wars: The Old Republic’s conversion to free-to-play to bring in more cash

Pictured: Frank Gibeau (left) and Dave Jedi (right)

EA’s recent investor call is a lesson in business expectation management. Before the call, EA announced the shift to a free-to-play business model. In the call, Frank Gibeau, the President of EA Labels, explained that the game and team would “pivot and provide a two-tiered pricing plan, which will make the game more accessible and grow the audience.” But later, Frank admitted that the new plan wouldn’t necessarily bring in more cash.

In an answer to an investor question, Frank explained that “the pivot to free-to-play is really about opening up the top of the funnel and getting more player through and starting claw back some of the folks that have churned [i.e. bought the game and cancelled their subscription]. But we don’t see free-to-play revenues as incremental to anything that we currently discussed on the call.”

What was surprising throughout the call was the open negativity surrounding the game coming from the EA execs. It was frequently described as “a disappointment”, and EA continually downplayed their expectations.

The problem: they’re probably right. I have serious doubts whether Star Wars: The Old Republic can seriously compete as a free-to-play game. The rules Bioware and EA will enforce with the conversion to free-to-play - the chance to play all levels from 1-50, is incredibly fair. But I’m just not sure the game’s good enough.

Free-to-play games thrive when the developers and publishers produce a relatively small content set and rapidly iterate and improve on the game. The Old Republic is a vast, vast game, but subscriber numbers have dropped off because the Bioware devs have only released three major updates in the year that the game’s been out for. The expectation was that players would be happy to go back and level new characters through the same world. That expectation was flat out wrong. Now, in the last month, the number of developers working on the game has been cut back through layoffs.

What a shame.

Login or Register
icheyne's picture

I don't think a lack of updates is the problem, just general disillusionment with the MMO format and an inability to establish a snowball of player numbers to rival WoW.


What is the best MMORPG on PC?

EA’s plan for Star Wars: CEO wants Arkham-style "deep, immersive storylines", not film tie-ins

Star Wars: The Old Republic expansion adds player strongholds and guild flagships

Pyramid scheme: The Old Republic's PvP Huttball to get a vertical makeover on April 8

Solving homelessness: The Old Republic to get player housing

SWTOR: Galactic Starfighter now available to everyone along with a gargantuan patch


Rift free-to-play vs everyone else’s free-to-play

Star Wars: The Old Republic's 2014: two new expansions and a storyline to span "the whole year"

A new hope: The Old Republic subscriptions "decline" as free-to-play "continues to grow"

The Old Republic Galactic Starfighter expansion brings the dogfight to (some) non-subscribers

BioWare's Old Republic studio hammering away at "several" unannounced projects

The Old Republic Galactic Starfighter expansion is live for subscribers

Star Wars: The Old Republic

The fall and rise of The Old Republic: “It's good times right now”

The Old Republic celebrates the consumption of turkey meat with a double XP weekend

EA implicate shrinking interest in MMOs in The Old Republic's free-to-play fate

Watch a minute and a half's footage of Star Wars: The Old Republic's dogfighting mode

Star Wars The Old Republic characters could lose their names next month

Star Wars: The Old Republic Galactic Starfighter expansion removes rails from space combat

Star Wars: The Old Republic

Star Wars: The Old Republic gaining 10,000 new players every day since going free-to-play

Star Wars: The Old Republic's new Operation boss is currently unbeatable

Star Wars: The Old Republic patch 2.4 brings The Dread War to the galaxy

The Old Republic update 2.4 kicks off the Dread War

Star Wars: The Old Republic expansion Rise of the Hutt Cartel now free to subscribers

EA appoint Matthew Bromberg as new head of Bioware