Ubisoft ditches Splinter Cell: Blacklist’s E3 torture scene | PCGamesN

XCOM: Enemy Within Long War mod ramps up the difficulty till you cry

Minecraft has now sold 17 million copies on PC

How Battlefield Hardline has got better since beta

Splinter Cell: Blacklist

Ubisoft ditches Splinter Cell: Blacklist’s E3 torture scene

Nobody’s sure whether it’s because Ubisoft have seen Zero Dark Thirty, or because of the pursed lips that greeted Splinter Cell: Blacklist’s E3 demo. But an interactive torture scene demonstrated to the public last year - in which Sam Fisher pokes a man with a knife in an attempt to drain answers from his body - is now gone from the game.

"Definitely we are not going to see when the game's coming out that there are torture scenes in it. That scene is not there anymore. I've not really heard anyone say they loved it," Blacklist producer Andrew Wilson told Eurogamer. "It wasn't nice to see any negative reaction to something you've thrown your life into."

Wilson suggested that the scene was not representative of the tone his team were gunning for. So why show it at E3?

"Because the nature of E3, there are certain things that are easier to demonstrate," said Wilson. ""The first thing I'd say about that is that possibly there was missing context - and in an unabridged snapshot, it seemed like pretty tough material. We've scaled a lot of that back, and as we've gone through the process of development there are always things that you feel are not working as well. Every game does this, and cuts certain things."

Ubisoft creative director Maxime Beland told Kotaku that torture might still be a part of Blacklist’s world - but players won’t be instigating it.

"No, there will not be interactive torture in Blacklist,” he explained. “On Conviction, we called those 'interrogations,' right? And it was kind of, my vision of Conviction was that the player to be in control all the time. We had no camera cuts, I always wanted to make it feel that it was nonstop.

"We're doing certain things with interrogation moments where you won't be in control, but you will be in control of what you do with the guy after. So again, embracing that lethal/nonlethal side."

Beland had a “big discussion” with game director Patrick Redding - whose baritone you’ll remember soundtracking various Far Cry 3 demonstrations - and the pair concluded that they haven’t found a way to have true moral choices in the game and “link it to gameplay”.

“As soon as you link it to gameplay, the player sees the matrix, he sees the gold pot at the end of the rainbow, and then he plays the system a lot more than he plays the true morality,” said Beland.

"What we talked about, and we had lunches and meetings about it, we said, let's try something where it's a true moral choice. You're not going to get a thousand dollars if you don't kill the guy and only five hundred if you do; let's remove all the gameplay part of it. Let's put the player into those situations, put them in control - because that's where games shine - and then, hopefully, we're treating it in a way that's mature, that's respectful, that will get people talking about it."

I’m reminded of BioShock’s much-discussed Little Sister choice - one that had true material consequences in-game. I know that I didn’t compromise my choice in the name of optimisation - but nor did I ever really need the material rewards promised. What do you think? Are Beland and Redding right to separate moral choices from their in-game incentives?

Thanks, GamesIndustry.

Login or Register
Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
The 100 Best Free PC Games

100 best free PC games

The 100 Best Free PC Games

XCOM: Enemy Within Long War mod ramps up the difficulty till you cry

XCOM: Enemy Within Long War mod ramps up the difficulty till you cry

Minecraft has now sold 17 million copies on PC

Minecraft has now sold 17 million copies on PC

How Battlefield Hardline has got better since beta

How Battlefield Hardline has got better since beta

Samsung White crowned League of Legends world champions in front of 40,000 in Seoul

Samsung White crowned League of Legends world champions in front of 40,000 in Seoul

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare system requirements are after your hard drive spacey

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare system requirements are after your hard drive spacey

Here's what's coming in EVE Online's Phoebe expansion, and beyond

EVE Online

Here's what's coming in EVE Online's Phoebe expansion, and beyond

Killing Floor celebrates Halloween with evil, demented killer toys and new maps

Killing Floor celebrates Halloween with evil, demented killer toys and new maps

Londinium's burning in this new Total War: Attila siege battle trailer

Londinium's burning in this new Total War: Attila siege battle trailer

Final Fantasy XIV: Heavensward expansion announced; coming Spring 2015

Final Fantasy XIV: Heavensward expansion announced; coming Spring 2015

Watch CCP's EVE Vegas event unfold on Twitch right now; find out what's in store for EVE Online

Watch CCP's EVE Vegas event unfold on Twitch right now; find out what's in store for EVE Online

Dota 2 team Arrow Gaming disqualified from The Summit 2 over match-fixing allegations

Dota 2 team Arrow Gaming disqualified from The Summit 2 over match-fixing allegations

Playing With Myself: Legend of Grimrock 2

Legend of Grimrock 2

Playing With Myself: Legend of Grimrock 2

Doughlightful: Bossa Studios announces I am Bread

Doughlightful: Bossa Studios announces I am Bread

Final Fantasy XIV patch 2.4 will bring Shiva, a naked guy and some glasses to Eorzea

Final Fantasy XIV patch 2.4 will bring Shiva, a naked guy and some glasses to Eorzea

Tired of Waiting: Asus gets off Valve Time and announces its console PC, the GR8

Tired of Waiting: Asus gets off Valve Time and announces its console PC, the GR8

Heroes of the Storm celebrates Halloween with the time-honoured tradition of getting new skins

Heroes of the Storm celebrates Halloween with the time-honoured tradition of getting new skins

Project CARS has hit a few speed bumps and won't reach the finish line until March 17th

Project CARS has hit a few speed bumps and won't reach the finish line until March 17th

Company of Heroes 2: Ardennes Assault is the single-player campaign you've been waiting for

Company of Heroes 2 - Ardennes Assault

Company of Heroes 2: Ardennes Assault is the single-player campaign you've been waiting for

Play Hearthstone and meet Blizzard's Hamilton Chu in Stratford next week

Play Hearthstone and meet Blizzard's Hamilton Chu in Stratford next week

Halo: Spartan Strike trailer promises top-down prometheans and warthogs

Halo: Spartan Strike trailer promises top-down prometheans and warthogs

Ubisoft won't stop PC players from fiddling with The Crew's frame-rate

Ubisoft won't stop PC players from fiddling with The Crew's frame-rate

Minecraft 1.8.1 will improve stability, make the ender dragon killable again

Minecraft 1.8.1 will improve stability, make the ender dragon killable again

AMD to cut 7% of workforce after iffy sales forecast

AMD to cut 7% of workforce after iffy sales forecast