Monolith debut PC footage for Middle-Earth Shadow of Mordor with new challenge mode

Oculus Rift Crescent Bay prototype features 360 tracking and integrated audio

League of Legends launching in Japan; world dominance almost complete

Why is Windows 8 “a catastrophe for anyone in the PC space”?

Gabe Newell gave the quote of the year today: “Windows 8 is a catastrophe for everyone in the PC space.” But the question is: why. What is it about Windows 8 that makes it such a disaster? As an experiment, I’ve been using Windows 8 for over two weeks as my main PC. I have no recourse to any other PC or OS to do work or play games. What’s gone wrong?

Metro apps are weird and baffling and makes no sense on a desktop.

The Metro interface you so regularly see on screenshots isn’t actually what you spend your days in. That only appears if you press the Start button, or if you’re in a specific Metro App. Windows 8 comes with a mishmash of desktop (otherwise known as ‘proper’) apps and Metro apps. Paint and Notepad, for instance are desktop apps. But certain essentials are Metro: the default email and Instant Message apps are full screen, big text affairs.

It isn’t just that the Metro apps are bad, although they mostly are. It’s that Metro itself is a distraction engine: it doesn’t let you concentrate on the task your completing. And moving between the two interface paradigms to complete a single piece of work is frustrating and annoying. Metro belongs on tablets. It doesn’t belong on the desktop.

So why are Microsoft so keen to foist it on gamers? 

Windows 8 wants to take your money, day in-day out

Windows 8 is the cheapest operating system Microsoft have ever put out. But that's fine, because those who use it will be squeezed for every penny. Windows 8 is all about consumption: about watching Videos, listening to Music, and playing games; all bought from the three stores built into the Windows interface. If you’re a gamer, your credit details are instantly added to your Windows 8 account the moment you log in (mine were transferred from my XBox Live account), and you’re invited to go shopping. The Metro video player is also an aggressive shop. As is the Metro Music player: they all invite you to make further purchases.

The real issue for gamers is the Windows 8 Store, where you can buy new apps. We all know that the most popular apps will be games.

Windows 8 has no interest in promoting high-end PC games

The guidelines for getting your app or game listed in the Windows 8 store are fiercely weighted towards touch and Metro apps. If you want to be listed, your app has to start in two seconds or less. It must include a snapped view (i.e. be playable while taking up a third, or two thirds of the desktop). There are guidelines on how the app behaves in low power state, to the type of content it can include. Frankly, most of today’s games just wouldn’t be allowed on the store: “Your app must not contain content that encourages, facilitates or glamorizes extreme or gratuitous violence, human rights violations, or the creation or use of weapons against a person or animal in the real world.”

Even if you pass the taste test, the Windows Store offers fresh headaches. To create a game for the store, it must be packaged via Windows RunTime, a new development environment introduced in 2011. The good news is that if you create a Windows RunTime app, it will run on both Intel and ARM processors. The bad news is that Microsoft are pushing for RunTime to become the dominant programming environment from today. RunTime is built for Metro, which was built for touch. Microsoft want developers to make touch programs.

Microsoft believe that touch = profit

Right now, Microsoft don’t get a cut from PC software sold and they have to rely on outside sources to make great hardware. Microsoft’s success is predicated on developers and hardware manufacturers doing great work.

That business model was a success story in the last decade, but it knows it can do better: while the Windows division still accounts for the vast majority of Microsoft’s business, it knows that there’s more money to be made. They only have to look at the success of Apple’s hardware, from the iPod to the iPhone to the iPad, to see that melding a hardware platform to a software or content store can deliver vast profits.

In the long term, Microsoft want to take a cut from any software or content sold on its devices. And Microsoft also knows that the only growing market for computers is in portable devices like laptops and tablets. Microsoft’s strategy is to weld portable computing with desktop computing, by pushing a Metro interface onto the desktop. In the process they get to approve all apps, determine what content reaches customers, and crucially, take a cut from everything sold.

The problem for those who rely on open platforms: Apple showed that that strategy works.

Microsoft are willing to throw their hardware partners under a bus to make Metro work

The announcement of the Surface Pro tablets came as a surprise, not just to consumers, but to PC manufacturers. With the Surface tablet, Microsoft are now setting the precedent that they are willing to compete with their hardware partners by building their own devices. For a third party hardware manufacturer with Windows 8 tablets in development, Microsoft’s moves are a signficant threat. Expect Microsoft’s tablet team to work closely with the Windows 8 developers to optimise and improve their own hardware efforts, and expect the Tablet team to co-opt Windows 8 marketing to promote their own hardware. Expect, too, Microsoft’s own tablet to be significantly better than what their competitors produce.

What’s worrying for PC gamers and hardware manufacturers is that Microsoft are now offering a hardware alternative that competes directly with the traditional PC and laptop. When it comes to their next PC purchase, consumers get a choice: a desktop, a laptop, or a shiny Windows tablet.

There is a place for games on the Windows 8. It’s called the Xbox

There are some clues as to Microsoft’s next-gen gaming strategy in Windows 8. The first is the Xbox Companion - an app that lets you control your Xbox from your PC, tablet or laptop. You can start games, message friends, close apps and move through menus in much the same way that the companion apps for iOS and Android work. I’m still trying to work out ‘why’.

The second is the Xbox Store - a separate app that lets you buy Xbox games from your PC and have them download automatically onto your Xbox hard-drive. Within the Xbox store, hidden behind sub-menus around at the back, there is also a placeholder PC game store.

Yes. Microsoft is happy to sell you PC games. But only from the Xbox store.  

I wonder if, when the Xbox 8 is launched, it will essentially be a Metro PC that’s hooked up to your television - able to run all the Metro apps you’ve bought from the Windows 8 store, the Xbox games you’ve bought, and the PC games Microsoft deem acceptable to list in the PC section of the Xbox store. The implications of that to the PC gaming industry are beyond enormous.

Closed platforms close off innovation

The PC’s openness is what makes it great. Everything we take for granted about PC gaming is based around it being open to all to develop, promote and create. On an open platform, an entrepreneur like Gabe can build a digital distribution network that reaches 40 million players. On an open platform, the business case exists for creating expansion cards and upgrades for our hardware that delivers faster, better graphics. On an open platform, a huge business like Blizzard can invest billions to producing a world conquering MMO, safe in the knowledge that they get to own the proceeds. On an open platform, game developers are safe to produce, innovate and create without fear of an approval process, of paying for patch distribution, or their entire business model being outlawed by an ever changing EULA. Open platforms encourage innovation.

Before Gabe Newell called Windows 8 a catastrophe, he called out Apple for their closed nature. “It’s sort of ominous that the world seems to be moving away from open platforms. I’m worried that the things that traditionally have been the source of a lot of innovation are going – there’s going to be an attempt to close those off so somebody will say ‘I’m tired of competing with Google, I’m tired of competing with Facebook, I’ll apply a console model and exclude the competitors I don’t like from my world.’”

At the time, he singled out Apple: “I suspect Apple will launch a living room product that redefines people’s expectations really strongly and the notion of a separate console platform will disappear,” he warned.

Since then, Microsoft turned into the aggressor.

Login or Register
0
+0
-0
avatar

"Yes. Windows 8 will let you buy PC games, but only from the Xbox store."

That statement is completely false. You can still install standard programs, such as Steam, just as you did in Windows 7.

0
+0
-0
avatar

Absolutely well written and concise explaining the technical and philosophical reasons why content creators like Valve and Blizzard should be worried about Windows 8 especially since a lot of people are clueless on what the shift from Win32 to Win32 really means. I am surprised this article isn't cited more often. Bravo

0
+0
-0
avatar

Key correction- "shift from Win32 to Win32 really means" to "Win 32 to Win RT"

0
+0
-0
avatar

Oh NO! I better go uninstall all my Windows XP and Windows 7 based games... I didn't know they didn't work. /sarcasm

0
+0
-0
avatar

Game companies like valve (steam) and blizzard (bnet) should be scared of windows 8. Windows 8 store is incredibly easy to use and download entertaining games almost instantly for very cheap. This is especially bad for steam since it tries (but isn't as good) to do the same thing. Should gamers care? No, we still will have our normal flux of AAA PC games and the start screen works exactly like and as fast as the start menu, except (oh no!) it takes up the whole screen.

0
+0
-0
avatar

You guys making this out to be not a big deal are foolish. Will all the games you have now still work? Most likely. Will you be able to get more games like them? Most likely. Is a trend towards homogenizing desktops and tablets while moving more towards a closed platform horrifying? Fucking yes, it is. Who in their right mind wants the two biggest, and therefore influential, computer designers making a bunch of touch-screen bullshit while making it harder for developers to make content?

0
+0
-0
avatar

Probably worth adding an update to this post now that Windows 8 is actually out, acknowledging that it was an ill-informed, inaccurate and just plain ridiculous piece of FUD.

0
+0
-0
avatar

All Win8 does for me is crash repeatedly when I play GW2. I'm guaranteed at least 3 BSoD's a night.. That is the only consistent about this new release.

Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
ArcheAge review in progress

ArcheAge

ArcheAge review in progress

Monolith debut PC footage for Middle-Earth Shadow of Mordor with new challenge mode

Monolith debut PC footage for Middle-Earth Shadow of Mordor with new challenge mode

Oculus Rift Crescent Bay prototype features 360 tracking and integrated audio

Oculus Rift Crescent Bay prototype features 360 tracking and integrated audio

League of Legends launching in Japan; world dominance almost complete

League of Legends launching in Japan; world dominance almost complete

Love Loadout? You can play the campaign beta on Steam for free

Love Loadout? You can play the campaign beta on Steam for free

Heroes of the Storm enters final phase of technical alpha on Monday

Heroes of the Storm enters final phase of technical alpha on Monday

Our best Diablo 3 builds

Diablo III

Our best Diablo 3 builds

Australians can download the uncensored Left 4 Dead 2 today via DLC

Australians can download the uncensored Left 4 Dead 2 today via DLC

The Red Bull Battle Grounds Grand Final invades Washington D.C.

The Red Bull Battle Grounds Grand Final invades Washington D.C.

Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4 "Autumn Patch" sheds all the bugs; further improves netcode

Meet Kilrogg: Warlords of Draenor's cyclopean berserker

Meet Kilrogg: Warlords of Draenor's cyclopean berserker

No rest for the wicked: Triad Wars, the Sleeping Dogs spin-off, will be unveiled on Monday

No rest for the wicked: Triad Wars, the Sleeping Dogs spin-off, will be unveiled on Monday

Train Simulator 2015 interview: “Oculus Rift is just perfect complementary technology for Train Simulator”

Train Simulator 2015

Train Simulator 2015 interview: “Oculus Rift is just perfect complementary technology for Train Simulator”

Clarion Call 4 is an impressive player-made EVE Online propaganda film

Clarion Call 4 is an impressive player-made EVE Online propaganda film

Drive Angry: Battlefield Hardline's Hotwire mode is all about driving fast

Drive Angry: Battlefield Hardline's Hotwire mode is all about driving fast

Battleborn's debut is flashy but familiar

Battleborn's debut is flashy but familiar

Farming Simulator 15 declares war on trees; launches on October 30th

Farming Simulator 15 declares war on trees; launches on October 30th

Elite: Dangerous beta phase two launches on September 30th

Elite: Dangerous beta phase two launches on September 30th

How Crusader Kings 2 caught Paradox by surprise

Crusader Kings II

How Crusader Kings 2 caught Paradox by surprise

Radiation warning: Wasteland 2 launches - and it's great

Radiation warning: Wasteland 2 launches - and it's great

Road Redemption trailer marks Steam Early Access. The game where it rains cars

Road Redemption trailer marks Steam Early Access. The game where it rains cars

Age of Wonders III update 1.4 and Golden Realms expansion released

Age of Wonders III update 1.4 and Golden Realms expansion released

Spacebase DF-9 release window set. Time Travel, holodecks, and killer robots cut

Spacebase DF-9 release window set. Time Travel, holodecks, and killer robots cut

Scrolls price drops to compete on tablets

Scrolls price drops to compete on tablets