Europa Universalis IV
179 days 9 hours
125 days 8 hours
Crusader Kings II
116 days 20 hours
52 days 12 hours
People who dislike this game who play it long enough mostly end up loving it. Its that kinda game. For every valid point of a broken universe, when it clicks it really clicks. Its worth checking the "immersion" thread on the official forums of people getting sucked into it.
That's just not the case, sadly. Some of us have put in about 100 hours of actual play time (as opposed to staring in disbelief time) and it's just bad.
Every time I hear the police siren I die a little inside.