Valve believe microtransactions used for evil will ultimately "lose in the marketplace" | PCGamesN

League of Legends Championship Series' spring split ends with series of tie-breakers

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare's Ascendance DLC continues the adventures of John Malkovich and chums

Hearthstone: Blackrock Mountain: all the new cards

Dota 2

Valve believe microtransactions used for evil will ultimately "lose in the marketplace"

Team Fortress 2

Microtransactions, like wrist-based web-sacs, are tools to be used responsibly. It’s no news that when they’re not, players can be left feeling cheated and unhappy, with an undesirable leather-to-coin wallet contents ratio. But on top of that, professional Half-Life-skirkers Valve reckon that a morally unsound approach to in-game economies isn’t financially sound either.

“All of these things lead to regret,” said Valve’s Kyle Davis. “And regret leads to effectively training your customers to stop buying things from you.”

“It’s our belief - and we have a lot of data to back up this belief - that products that use microtransactions or economic systems as tools for maximising revenue from unhappy users will lose in the marketplace,” said Davis in a Steam Dev Days talk about the in-game economies of TF2 and Dota.

Attracting long-term, happy customers is one of Valve’s core philosophies, said Davis, and any cash that comes at a cost of consumer happiness is something they want to avoid “at all costs”.

“To be really concrete: we would rather someone not become a customer of ours, rather than them become a customer and be unhappy about that decision,” explained Davis.

New to Dota 2 and don't know which heroes to play? Take a gander at our best Dota 2 heroes for beginners guide.

As a result, Valve don’t hurry to find the maximum value in their games at launch. They’d rather wait a while to find a way to get rich that will also turn players into happy customers.

Internally, Valve have a ‘regret test’. Testers play with a new system, and developers find out, a day or a week later, whether they’re “still happy with their interactions”. The process then continues once a feature is shipped. Valve collect data from the public to find out whether they’re regretting their purchases later - and if so, they do something about it. 

“We view any system that generates value at a cost to customer happiness as a broken system that we need to fix,” said Davis.

Davis pointed out, perhaps unnecessarily, that a lot of “really pervasive” microtransaction systems in the games industry currently “violate” the principles Valve have set out for themselves. They create artificial barriers and charge to remove them, earning money without providing a service to the player. They rely on virtual currencies which “obfuscate” pricing, or trap user money inside the game’s system.

It’s an approach that inevitably leads to regret, said Davis, which is “incredibly damaging long-term”.

Let’s talk about this, then: what in-game purchases do you regret making? And which are you still happy to remember?

Login or Register
1
+1
-0
clownp33n13's picture
1

in the 3 years ive been playing dota2 i have spent 300+

im including a headset and apparel that included in game items.

alot of those older items that came from the shirts mice and headsets are really keeping value.

my question would be what if valve just decides to end dota2?

what would happen with our inventories?

please i need answers lol

1
+1
-0
subedii's picture
406

I always see references to how the "masses" (or whatever) don't hold to these theories because they're so stupid. But then it's hard for me to not see similar happening when I look at what happened to Zynga. Zynga was the "golden child", the one everyone wanted to (and did) emulate, and now, well...

I don't think these things happen immediately, but I do believe it's very possible to damage your brand over time through such practices. Once people adjust to the practices and start to familiarise themselves with the mechanics at play, there's often a sharp drop off in willingness to participate.

Much like the general Free-2-Play bandwaggon jumping PC-side, the only games of those that have really managed to be successful and thrive (let alone just plain survive) are the ones where the monetisation doesn't feel like it's a roadblock to the fun.

1
+1
-0
Dog Pants's picture
1216

Unfortunately people likely to be posting here are likely to be the kind of people who don't do the silly mobile game MT thing. The £70 gem 'deals' in Dungeon Keeper. Well, not unfortunately for us, but unfortunately for the sake of discussion.

Personally I'll buy microtransaction stuff if I feel a sense of investment in a game before I spend anything. I've probably spent £40 in Planetside 2, all with cheap SC and mostly on sales. Some is weaponry, most is hideous purple tigerstripe spandex. For me it all comes down to whether I can enjoy the game for the same or less than what I would have been prepared to pay up front. So conversely, even though I enjoy Guild Wars 2, I already paid £50 for it so I'm not really inclined to spend any more.

0
+1
-1
Sax's picture
156

Or you just have to very clever in your evilness, see trading cards.

2
+2
-0
Reikhardt's picture
100

How are trading cards evil? You're free to ignore them and they're nothing to do with the games they come from.

1
+1
-0
Shriven's picture
2186

They have monetised Steam. Totally optional thing.

0
+1
-1
Sax's picture
156

They are not optional. Every Steam user takes part automatically. As soon as you run games you receive cards. Which is, of course, intentional. You can let them amass in you inventory or you can take the "free money" and sell them on the market. That's what most people who don't want to craft badges will do.

Valve profits from every sold or bought item.

1
+1
-0
Denterroquet's picture
1

Actually, if you want to receive cards, you have to join the Steam Card group.

Try these free to play games
?

These are affiliate links - clicking them and playing the games directly supports PCGamesN

Spotlight
?

Our Spotlight units plug content our journalists have made, that our advertisers want to promote. Sometimes the promotion is paid for, but the content they go to is always independent with no client oversight or approval.


Alienware - Game VictoriousTurtle Beach
NewBee wins the 2014 Dota 2 International

Dota 2

NewBee wins the 2014 Dota 2 International

Dota 2 player recreates Valve's

Dota 2 player recreates Valve's "failed" Faceless Void concept in-game

Dota 2 International tickets go on sale next week in two batches

Dota 2 International tickets go on sale next week in two batches

Red Bull Battle Grounds adds a Dota 2 tournament circuit; grand final kicks off on May 10th

Red Bull Battle Grounds adds a Dota 2 tournament circuit; grand final kicks off on May 10th

Dota 2's Faceless Void gets a facelift; see Valve's hilarious

Dota 2's Faceless Void gets a facelift; see Valve's hilarious "failed" concepts

Vote goat: Goat Simulator developers want to put their goat in Dota 2

Vote goat: Goat Simulator developers want to put their goat in Dota 2

Dota 2 International main event: Day Two

Dota 2

Dota 2 International main event: Day Two

Valve vow to

Valve vow to "do a better job of walking people through what we're doing"

ESL increases prize pool for ESL One Dota 2 series to a million dollars

ESL increases prize pool for ESL One Dota 2 series to a million dollars

Steam racks up 125 million active accounts, with help from Dota 2 and Counter-Strike

Steam racks up 125 million active accounts, with help from Dota 2 and Counter-Strike

Dota 2 sees over one million players concurrently for New Bloom event; servers struggle with load

Dota 2 sees over one million players concurrently for New Bloom event; servers struggle with load

Dota 2 New Bloom festival to return; features new Winter Wyvern hero

Dota 2 New Bloom festival to return; features new Winter Wyvern hero

Dota 2 International main event: Day One

Dota 2

Dota 2 International main event: Day One

Valve open new curated Steam Workshops. Creators have made more than $57m since 2011

Valve open new curated Steam Workshops. Creators have made more than $57m since 2011

Dota 2 Asia Championships prize pool breaches $2 million dollars

Dota 2 Asia Championships prize pool breaches $2 million dollars

Get ready for the Dota 2 International 2015

Get ready for the Dota 2 International 2015

Dota 2 modeller builds GabeN Shopkeeper in time for New Bloom

Dota 2 modeller builds GabeN Shopkeeper in time for New Bloom

Dota 2 heralds the new year with over ten million unique players last month

Dota 2 heralds the new year with over ten million unique players last month

What to expect from the Dota 2 International main event

Dota 2

What to expect from the Dota 2 International main event

The best Dota 2 Heroes for beginners

The best Dota 2 Heroes for beginners

Dota 2's Frostivus may be canceled, but that's not stopped Valve shipping patch 6.83: Shifting Snows

Dota 2's Frostivus may be canceled, but that's not stopped Valve shipping patch 6.83: Shifting Snows

Red Bull's Seattle Dota LAN is cooking up a randomised team tournament with over 100 players

Red Bull's Seattle Dota LAN is cooking up a randomised team tournament with over 100 players

Dota 2's Frostivus event is cancelled, again; team to instead work on engine update

Dota 2's Frostivus event is cancelled, again; team to instead work on engine update

YouPorn eSports team revealed: Play2Win become Team YP

YouPorn eSports team revealed: Play2Win become Team YP