Hi-Rez: Steam free-to-play games have a discovery problem

Watch a man and his elephant go clay human shooting in Far Cry 4

Na'Vi Dota 2 squad has "lost its leader": Puppey moves on with "no regrets"

Gulp: tattoo copyright now officially videogames' problem

Copyright law is guided by precedent, and recent signs point to future trouble for publishers with real-world tattoos in their games. Legal tongues were sent wagging after the body artist behind Mike Tyson’s face thing settled a Hangover lawsuit with Warner Bros. two years ago. And now the scribbler of professional mixed martial artist Carlos Condit’s ribcage lion tattoo, seen in UFC Undisputed, has approached a US bankruptcy judge to value the worth of an infringement claim against THQ.

Yup: bankrupt THQ.

Under US copyright law, tattoo art qualifies for protection as “an original work of expression fixed in a tangible medium”.

The artist in question, Christopher Escobedo, originally sued THQ back in November. Thanks to THQ’s expiration shortly thereafter, his lawsuit has since played out in bankruptcy court.

Escobedo initially filed a claim for $4.16 million - by his reckoning, he was entitled to a 2% cut of all post-bankruptcy sales of UFC Undisputed. The bankruptcy judge disagreed, instead valuing the claim at $22,500 - the same amount Condit himself was paid for the use of his image in the game.

Here’s where things get interesting, however. Escobedo’s attorney asked the judge to reconsider. He pointed out that 4.1 million units of UFC Undisputed had been sold, and that former Interim UFC Welterweight champion Condit was one of the “most popular figures” in the game. Furthermore, the tattoo in question is reportedly visible for a full 15 minutes in the game’s opening.

Therefore, he suggested, the court should determine “what royalty a hypothetical negotiation between Escobedo and THQ would have produced” - adding that the tattoo image was in some respects more valuable to THQ than the music licensed for the game.

“THQ had literally millions of songs to choose from when deciding what music clips to include in its games,” read the motion for reconsideration. “There was no restriction on their choice. Thus, they had the opportunity to choose the least expensive music license they could get. To produce a UFC computer game, however, THQ had a limited number of fighters to choose from and had no choice but to either not include the fighter's tattoo on the avatars or include it. 

“That fact alone would have placed Escobedo in a very different bargaining position than the music publisher and makes it likely that Escobedo would have negotiated a per game royalty rather than a one-time fee.”

In response, THQ’s reps made a series of persuasive points: that one tattoo among over 100 fighters represented “exceedingly low value” (somebody ought to check these documents for the name ‘Kipling’); that there was a “likelihood” that a tattoo on another person’s body wasn’t copyrightable; that Condit’s licensing of his own image probably covered the tattoo too; and that, in any case, Condit should be considered the inky lion’s “joint author”. 

The bankruptcy judge ultimately kept his valuation at $22,500 - THQ had moved for a slightly cheaper $0 - but Escobedo is now appealing the order to a group of judges on a bankruptcy appellate panel.

After racking our brains for prominent in-game tattoos, we’ve come up with only BioShock Infinite and Far Cry 3: though I reckon their wholly fictional conception leaves 2K and Ubisoft safe from this sort of thing. Can you think of any others?

Thanks to @gamerlaw and the Hollywood Reporter for this one.

Login or Register
2
+2
-0
Sax's picture
153

Mirror's Edge, of course.

1
+1
-0
Jeremy Peel's picture
88

OF COURSE.

Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
Some new Star Citizen stretch goals thumbmail

Star Citizen

Some new Star Citizen stretch goals

Hi-Rez: Steam free-to-play games have a discovery problem thumnnail

Hi-Rez: Steam free-to-play games have a discovery problem

Watch a man and his elephant go clay human shooting in Far Cry 4 thumnnail

Watch a man and his elephant go clay human shooting in Far Cry 4

Na'Vi Dota 2 squad has

Na'Vi Dota 2 squad has "lost its leader": Puppey moves on with "no regrets"

Resident Evil: Revelations 2 box art and screenshot make a brief appearance thumnnail

Resident Evil: Revelations 2 box art and screenshot make a brief appearance

Hitting the bottle: Brainiac gets his own Lego Batman 3 trailer thumnnail

Hitting the bottle: Brainiac gets his own Lego Batman 3 trailer

Gamescom 2014: The Indie Games Roundup thumbmail

Verdun

Gamescom 2014: The Indie Games Roundup

Overkill's The Walking Dead takes place in the comic universe, but with new survivors thumnnail

Overkill's The Walking Dead takes place in the comic universe, but with new survivors

Hellgate is quietly attempting a comeback through Steam Greenlight thumnnail

Hellgate is quietly attempting a comeback through Steam Greenlight

Celebrate Final Fantasy XIV's anniversary with free game time thumnnail

Celebrate Final Fantasy XIV's anniversary with free game time

Sienna Storm: a spy thriller and digital card game from Deus Ex and Knights of the Old Republic 2 devs thumnnail

Sienna Storm: a spy thriller and digital card game from Deus Ex and Knights of the Old Republic 2 devs

Topic of the Week: Exclusives - what are they good for? thumbmail

Topic of the Week

Topic of the Week: Exclusives - what are they good for?

ESL One Cologne: 856 years of Counter-Strike was watched by nearly half a million people  thumnnail

ESL One Cologne: 856 years of Counter-Strike was watched by nearly half a million people

So many tears: here are seven minutes of The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth in co-op thumnnail

So many tears: here are seven minutes of The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth in co-op

Don't Starve Together closed beta planned for September thumnnail

Don't Starve Together closed beta planned for September

Valve voted the company developers most want to work for, ahead of BioWare and Ubisoft thumnnail

Valve voted the company developers most want to work for, ahead of BioWare and Ubisoft

Jonathan Blow and friends to fund Rainbow Six-ish tactical FPS Due Process thumnnail

Jonathan Blow and friends to fund Rainbow Six-ish tactical FPS Due Process

Who is the least worst publisher of PC games? EA or Ubisoft? thumbmail

EA

Who is the least worst publisher of PC games? EA or Ubisoft?

Atari's latest PC reboot is Alone in the Dark: Illumination thumnnail

Atari's latest PC reboot is Alone in the Dark: Illumination

How a working 1kb hard drive was built in Minecraft thumnnail

How a working 1kb hard drive was built in Minecraft

Blizzard don't expect World of Warcraft subscriptions to grow again thumnnail

Blizzard don't expect World of Warcraft subscriptions to grow again

Tee off: The Golf Club launches thumnnail

Tee off: The Golf Club launches

Rad news: Wasteland 2 is only a month away thumnnail

Rad news: Wasteland 2 is only a month away