Gulp: tattoo copyright now officially videogames' problem | PCGamesN

Hearthstone win trading results in permanent bans and tournament disqualification

Watch Dogs sold 9m copies. Ubisoft expect to make €1.4bn by end of financial year

Battlecry trailer reveals a bloody Wild West in a weird Eastern Bloc

Gulp: tattoo copyright now officially videogames' problem

Copyright law is guided by precedent, and recent signs point to future trouble for publishers with real-world tattoos in their games. Legal tongues were sent wagging after the body artist behind Mike Tyson’s face thing settled a Hangover lawsuit with Warner Bros. two years ago. And now the scribbler of professional mixed martial artist Carlos Condit’s ribcage lion tattoo, seen in UFC Undisputed, has approached a US bankruptcy judge to value the worth of an infringement claim against THQ.

Yup: bankrupt THQ.

Under US copyright law, tattoo art qualifies for protection as “an original work of expression fixed in a tangible medium”.

The artist in question, Christopher Escobedo, originally sued THQ back in November. Thanks to THQ’s expiration shortly thereafter, his lawsuit has since played out in bankruptcy court.

Escobedo initially filed a claim for $4.16 million - by his reckoning, he was entitled to a 2% cut of all post-bankruptcy sales of UFC Undisputed. The bankruptcy judge disagreed, instead valuing the claim at $22,500 - the same amount Condit himself was paid for the use of his image in the game.

Here’s where things get interesting, however. Escobedo’s attorney asked the judge to reconsider. He pointed out that 4.1 million units of UFC Undisputed had been sold, and that former Interim UFC Welterweight champion Condit was one of the “most popular figures” in the game. Furthermore, the tattoo in question is reportedly visible for a full 15 minutes in the game’s opening.

Therefore, he suggested, the court should determine “what royalty a hypothetical negotiation between Escobedo and THQ would have produced” - adding that the tattoo image was in some respects more valuable to THQ than the music licensed for the game.

“THQ had literally millions of songs to choose from when deciding what music clips to include in its games,” read the motion for reconsideration. “There was no restriction on their choice. Thus, they had the opportunity to choose the least expensive music license they could get. To produce a UFC computer game, however, THQ had a limited number of fighters to choose from and had no choice but to either not include the fighter's tattoo on the avatars or include it. 

“That fact alone would have placed Escobedo in a very different bargaining position than the music publisher and makes it likely that Escobedo would have negotiated a per game royalty rather than a one-time fee.”

In response, THQ’s reps made a series of persuasive points: that one tattoo among over 100 fighters represented “exceedingly low value” (somebody ought to check these documents for the name ‘Kipling’); that there was a “likelihood” that a tattoo on another person’s body wasn’t copyrightable; that Condit’s licensing of his own image probably covered the tattoo too; and that, in any case, Condit should be considered the inky lion’s “joint author”. 

The bankruptcy judge ultimately kept his valuation at $22,500 - THQ had moved for a slightly cheaper $0 - but Escobedo is now appealing the order to a group of judges on a bankruptcy appellate panel.

After racking our brains for prominent in-game tattoos, we’ve come up with only BioShock Infinite and Far Cry 3: though I reckon their wholly fictional conception leaves 2K and Ubisoft safe from this sort of thing. Can you think of any others?

Thanks to @gamerlaw and the Hollywood Reporter for this one.

Login or Register
2
+2
-0
Sax's picture
153

Mirror's Edge, of course.

1
+1
-0
Jeremy Peel's picture
98

OF COURSE.

Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
The best of the Steam Halloween Sale

Steam

The best of the Steam Halloween Sale

Hearthstone win trading results in permanent bans and tournament disqualification

Hearthstone win trading results in permanent bans and tournament disqualification

Watch Dogs sold 9m copies. Ubisoft expect to make €1.4bn by end of financial year

Watch Dogs sold 9m copies. Ubisoft expect to make €1.4bn by end of financial year

Battlecry trailer reveals a bloody Wild West in a weird Eastern Bloc

Battlecry trailer reveals a bloody Wild West in a weird Eastern Bloc

James Cameron calls VR “a yawn, frankly”

James Cameron calls VR “a yawn, frankly”

Prey 2 cancelled by Bethesda

Prey 2 cancelled by Bethesda

The Swindle is Spelunky meets Deus Ex, a stealth roguelike in a steampunk top hat

The Swindle

The Swindle is Spelunky meets Deus Ex, a stealth roguelike in a steampunk top hat

Far Cry 4's PvP will let you duke it out using armoured vehicles, magic animals and teleportation

Far Cry 4's PvP will let you duke it out using armoured vehicles, magic animals and teleportation

Survival management game This War of Mine gets a November release date and a gloomy trailer

Survival management game This War of Mine gets a November release date and a gloomy trailer

Hone your testicle shooting skills in Sniper Elite 3's free Shooting Range update

Hone your testicle shooting skills in Sniper Elite 3's free Shooting Range update

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare's live action trailer is leaking testosterone all over the carpet

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare's live action trailer is leaking testosterone all over the carpet

Techland's brought in a special kind of expert to help with Dying Light

Techland's brought in a special kind of expert to help with Dying Light

The 10 best World War 2 PC games

War Thunder

The 10 best World War 2 PC games

Alone in the Dark: Illumination and Haunted House: Cryptic Graves appear on Steam in time for Halloween

Alone in the Dark: Illumination and Haunted House: Cryptic Graves appear on Steam in time for Halloween

Assassin’s Creed Unity trailer transports our French Revolution assassin to WW2

Assassin’s Creed Unity trailer transports our French Revolution assassin to WW2

Shadow of Mordor DLC Lord of the Hunt detailed. Lead a ghul horde

Shadow of Mordor DLC Lord of the Hunt detailed. Lead a ghul horde

The Long Dark update doubles world size with new Coastal Highway

The Long Dark update doubles world size with new Coastal Highway

Enforcer: Police Crime Action is a full-blooded police simulator. Yet it’s hilarious

Enforcer: Police Crime Action

Enforcer: Police Crime Action is a full-blooded police simulator. Yet it’s hilarious

Expect the Inquisition: Dragon Age Keep open beta begins

Expect the Inquisition: Dragon Age Keep open beta begins

Assassin’s Creed Unity trailer shows off Nvidia Gameworks enhancements

Assassin’s Creed Unity trailer shows off Nvidia Gameworks enhancements

The Evil Within patch unlocks 30fps cap and adds option to remove black bars

The Evil Within patch unlocks 30fps cap and adds option to remove black bars

Scream Fortress has turned Team Fortress 2 into a urine-soaked carnival

Scream Fortress has turned Team Fortress 2 into a urine-soaked carnival

50-100 million Oculus Rifts will need to be sold for it to be a

50-100 million Oculus Rifts will need to be sold for it to be a "meaningful thing as a computing platform"