Monolith debut PC footage for Middle-Earth Shadow of Mordor with new challenge mode

Oculus Rift Crescent Bay prototype features 360 tracking and integrated audio

League of Legends launching in Japan; world dominance almost complete

Minecraft

Putt-Putt claim Minecraft and Don Mattrick are infringing on their copyright. Are Putt-Putt trolling us?

Putt-Putt, purveyor of fine minature golf courses all over America, have sent a cease and desist letter to Mojang and Don Mattrick, claiming that “Mojang AB’s use of the Putt-Putt name has benefited Mojang AB to the detriment of Putt-Putt”.

They included pictorial evidence of how this infringement has occurred.

I sense that Putt-Putt may not be entirely aware of how Minecraft works, nor what its responsibility for its players actions Mojang holds. I consulted Wikipedia on the issue and came up with Contributory Liability, a law that aims to tackle people who enable the infringement of copyright - after all, Mojang did not make these Putt-Putt levels but the levels couldn’t have been made without the game existing. Except, then Putt-Putt would need to prove that Mojang created a game that was in an incomplete state, one which spurred players to fix it themselves, pushing them to infringe on other another company’s copyright. 

That would be difficult to prove.

These Putt-Putt levels aren't fixing issues in a broken game, so the responsibility of their creation falls to the modders themselves.

News of the legal action was announced my Minecraft’s creator Markus Perrson through Twitter:

Putt-Putt have chucked in Don Mattrick’s name into the cease and desist, too, presumably because of his relationship to the Xbox 360 (he was the president of the Interactive Entertainment Business at Microsoft, though recently announced he was leaving to become CEO of Zynga).

Login or Register
1
+1
-0
avatar
20

"Except, then Putt-Putt would need to prove that Mojang created a game that was in an incomplete state,..." - wasn't Minecraft distributed precisely in that manner, though?

Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
The 100 Best Minecraft Skins

Minecraft

The 100 Best Minecraft Skins

Microsoft rumoured to announce $2.5 billion purchase of Mojang on Monday

Microsoft rumoured to announce $2.5 billion purchase of Mojang on Monday

Microcraft: Microsoft might be trying to buy Mojang

Microcraft: Microsoft might be trying to buy Mojang

Mojang postpone Minecon until 2015; still to take place in London

Mojang postpone Minecon until 2015; still to take place in London

Build a clinic in Minecraft and help build a real one in Liberia

Build a clinic in Minecraft and help build a real one in Liberia

Topic of the Week: What are your fondest memories of Minecraft so far?

Minecraft

Topic of the Week: What are your fondest memories of Minecraft so far?

Aerna creators claim it's the largest and most detailed Minecraft server

Aerna creators claim it's the largest and most detailed Minecraft server

Snapshot 14w28b brings Minecraft closer to 1.8

Snapshot 14w28b brings Minecraft closer to 1.8

Knights beware: Minecraft snapshot 14w27a introduces bunnies

Knights beware: Minecraft snapshot 14w27a introduces bunnies

Minecrafting: Getting Started with Feed The Beast

Minecrafting: Getting Started with Feed The Beast

Minecrafting 152: Burning Flesh

Minecrafting 152: Burning Flesh

Dear Microsoft: about that Minecraft deal

Minecraft

Dear Microsoft: about that Minecraft deal

You're gonna need a bigger boat: Mojang's next mob will leave Minecraft's waters hostile

You're gonna need a bigger boat: Mojang's next mob will leave Minecraft's waters hostile

Minecrafting 151: A Natural Nether

Minecrafting 151: A Natural Nether

Minecraft EULA changes incoming;

Minecraft EULA changes incoming; "you cannot make money with Minecraft without our permission" says Erik Broes

Minecrafting 150: Bingo!

Minecrafting 150: Bingo!

Minecrafting 149: Pig Fireworks

Minecrafting 149: Pig Fireworks

The 50 best Minecraft maps

Minecraft

The 50 best Minecraft maps

You can now learn Japanese by playing Minecraft

You can now learn Japanese by playing Minecraft

Minecrafting 148: Kidnapping Villagers

Minecrafting 148: Kidnapping Villagers

Minecrafting 147: Drop Challenges

Minecrafting 147: Drop Challenges

Minecraft Realms expands to more countries

Minecraft Realms expands to more countries

Molyneux fawns over Minecraft again, this time for breaking

Molyneux fawns over Minecraft again, this time for breaking "game design rules"