Putt-Putt claim Minecraft and Don Mattrick are infringing on their copyright. Are Putt-Putt trolling us? | PCGamesN

Topic of the Week: What do you look for in a remastered game?

Grim Fandango Remastered PC review

Making it in Unreal: flipping through the X-Files with extraterrestrial horror game The Hum

Minecraft

Putt-Putt claim Minecraft and Don Mattrick are infringing on their copyright. Are Putt-Putt trolling us?

Putt-Putt, purveyor of fine minature golf courses all over America, have sent a cease and desist letter to Mojang and Don Mattrick, claiming that “Mojang AB’s use of the Putt-Putt name has benefited Mojang AB to the detriment of Putt-Putt”.

They included pictorial evidence of how this infringement has occurred.

I sense that Putt-Putt may not be entirely aware of how Minecraft works, nor what its responsibility for its players actions Mojang holds. I consulted Wikipedia on the issue and came up with Contributory Liability, a law that aims to tackle people who enable the infringement of copyright - after all, Mojang did not make these Putt-Putt levels but the levels couldn’t have been made without the game existing. Except, then Putt-Putt would need to prove that Mojang created a game that was in an incomplete state, one which spurred players to fix it themselves, pushing them to infringe on other another company’s copyright. 

That would be difficult to prove.

These Putt-Putt levels aren't fixing issues in a broken game, so the responsibility of their creation falls to the modders themselves.

News of the legal action was announced my Minecraft’s creator Markus Perrson through Twitter:

Putt-Putt have chucked in Don Mattrick’s name into the cease and desist, too, presumably because of his relationship to the Xbox 360 (he was the president of the Interactive Entertainment Business at Microsoft, though recently announced he was leaving to become CEO of Zynga).

Login or Register
1
+1
-0
avatar
21

"Except, then Putt-Putt would need to prove that Mojang created a game that was in an incomplete state,..." - wasn't Minecraft distributed precisely in that manner, though?

Try these free to play games
?

These are affiliate links - clicking them and playing the games directly supports PCGamesN

Spotlight
?

Our Spotlight units plug content our journalists have made, that our advertisers want to promote. Sometimes the promotion is paid for, but the content they go to is always independent with no client oversight or approval.


Alienware - Game VictoriousTurtle Beach
The Best of Minecraft in 2014

Minecraft

The Best of Minecraft in 2014

Minecraft's Ender Dragon will be getting a makeover for 1.9

Minecraft's Ender Dragon will be getting a makeover for 1.9

Phishers leak 1,800 Minecraft players' details to the web

Phishers leak 1,800 Minecraft players' details to the web

Minecraft name changes will be made possible on February 4

Minecraft name changes will be made possible on February 4

Minecraft regularly gets more than 1m players playing concurrently

Minecraft regularly gets more than 1m players playing concurrently

Mojang will let you shed your old Minecraft username

Mojang will let you shed your old Minecraft username

How to celebrate Christmas in Minecraft: mods, maps and skins

Minecraft

How to celebrate Christmas in Minecraft: mods, maps and skins

Notch's $70 million mansion rebuilt in Minecraft (sports cars not included)

Notch's $70 million mansion rebuilt in Minecraft (sports cars not included)

Notch just bought a house

Notch just bought a house

Minecraft 1.8.2 pre-released with altered explosion physics and better performance

Minecraft 1.8.2 pre-released with altered explosion physics and better performance

Chortle: The Beano commission official Dennis and Gnasher Minecraft mod

Chortle: The Beano commission official Dennis and Gnasher Minecraft mod

Cubism: Tate gallery make Minecraft maps of some of history's best-loved paintings

Cubism: Tate gallery make Minecraft maps of some of history's best-loved paintings

The 100 Best Minecraft Skins

Minecraft

The 100 Best Minecraft Skins

Minecraft and Mojang are now officially resting in Microsoft's belly

Minecraft and Mojang are now officially resting in Microsoft's belly

Update for Minecraft will let you control the fanciness of clouds

Update for Minecraft will let you control the fanciness of clouds

Minecraft 2 unlikely from Microsoft:

Minecraft 2 unlikely from Microsoft: "We need to meet the needs of the community"

Minecraft has now sold 17 million copies on PC

Minecraft has now sold 17 million copies on PC

Minecraft 1.8.1 will improve stability, make the ender dragon killable again

Minecraft 1.8.1 will improve stability, make the ender dragon killable again

Dear Microsoft: about that Minecraft deal

Minecraft

Dear Microsoft: about that Minecraft deal

Minecraft Movie lures Night at the Museum director Shawn Levy

Minecraft Movie lures Night at the Museum director Shawn Levy

Ordnance Survey upscale Minecraft map of Great Britain to be

Ordnance Survey upscale Minecraft map of Great Britain to be "more realistic"

British Museum to be officially rebuilt in Minecraft

British Museum to be officially rebuilt in Minecraft

Garry Newman on Mojang sale to Microsoft:

Garry Newman on Mojang sale to Microsoft: "I'd have done the same thing"

How much of Microsoft's $2.5 billion will Notch actually receive?

How much of Microsoft's $2.5 billion will Notch actually receive?