SimCity: Cities Of Tomorrow PC review | PCGamesN

Grand Ages: Medieval features more volcanoes than is reasonable for a game set in this period in history

Prison Architect Update 27 fixes the problems caused by teleporting food

Maia Update 0.46 video squishes bugs, adds botany and body bags

SimCity: Cities Of Tomorrow PC review

SimCity Maxis EA

Since SimCity came out in March, there have been eight patches for the troubled city building game. At times, the Cities of Tomorrow expansion feels like patch number nine. Its future-themed additions are smartly designed to counter the GlassBox engine's intractable problems. 

Were you annoyed by the cramped quarters you were given to build within in the original game? Cities of Tomorrow doesn't make the space larger, but instead introduces MegaTowers. 'Build up, not out!' pleads one of your citizens.

Were you annoyed by the pathfinding, which left your highways neglected while cars piled up on small roads and sims failed to find the shops opposite their house? Those eight patches made progress on the issue, but Cities of Tomorrow introduces elevated railways, skyways to connect MegaTowers, and drones, and each help keep sims indoors and off the streets.

These futuristic additions are introduced via three new specialisations. The Academy is a research center for unlocking new technologies, like wave generators, air scrubbers and those skyways. The Academy also generates ControlNet, a new resource which is quantum (i.e., it doesn't have to simulate its flow along roads), created by attracting different classes of workers to the Academy, and which is used to power most of the new futuristic buildings.

SimCity Maxis EA

The OmegaHQ is a new type of factory, which uses oil and ore to produce a mysterious new substance called "Omega", which everyone in your city loves. The effect is that a successful OmegaHQ will convert other industrial buildings to Omega franchises, and when you eventually start producing drones, residential and commercial buildings as well. It's a way of re-decorating your city with a futuristic sheen. 

Lastly, there's the MegaTowers, Ballardian skyscrapers designed to contain everything a sim might need in a single vast, multi-tiered structure. You build them chunk by chunk, plopping down mall levels atop office levels atop mile high park levels. 

That allows you to reach higher populations than in the base game, without using any more space. It also allows you to build cities which look radically different than before, or quickly give your existing successful cities a new look. If you aim for low and mid-wealth MegaTowers, your city will be marked by Blade Runner-esque black buildings and glowing neon. If you aim for high wealth and build Elite MegaTowers, your city will look like concept art for an as yet unbuilt smart city.

SimCity Maxis EA 

This makes up for a lot. There was a joy, even in the original, to watching your city tick over. That feeling is doubled when there are mag levs wooshing around amidst your skyscrapers, or drones floating amidst your factory's purple smoke. SimCity is more beautiful than ever, and as a fan of the main game in spite of its flaws, the changes in appearance were enough to draw me back and keep me playing for another ten hours. 

Much like the base game though, you'll enjoy the process a lot more if you don't think about it too much. If you do, Cities of Tomorrow starts to crumble at its foundations. 

These new specialisations radically alter the way your city looks, but they don't much alter the basic process of playing. You'll need to make sure your ControlNet supply expands, but the process of doing so is the same as anything else, accomplished by making sure your city attracts all the different classes of people. 

You don't have to think about anything new, which is why your existing cities can push through the new content so quickly. The aesthetic changes, coupled with the boosts in scale to your likely population, money and resource output are all welcome, but I don't think there's enough that's really new here to justify the £25/$30 price.

SimCity Maxis EA 

As much as the patches have helped, there's still lots of frustration left in the simulation. Placing streets can still be a fiddly nightmare. Much like the street dwellers, MegaTower residents will still sometimes struggle to find the shops directly above their heads. Your city's buildings and utilities still sometimes act in erratic ways, either due to bugs or a lack of clarity. When my city is full of recyclables, and I have lots of recycling trucks, and I have a factory designed to turn those recyclables into different materials, why is it not collecting or producing anything? I have no idea.

 On my aging rig - an overclocked AMD Phenom 2 with 4GB of RAM and a Radeon HD 5700 - Cities of Tomorrow ran exactly as well as the base game. That means that it hovered smoothly around the 30 frames per second mark, dropping occasionally to a still playable 20fps during particularly packed scenes. 

More than likely, the technical limitation that's going to bother you is the final fault of the original game I still haven't mentioned. Were you annoyed by its demand for an internet connection, even if you wanted to play alone? 

Then unfortunately, Cities of Tomorrow has nothing to offer you. The content it adds is beautiful, appealing to existing fans, and often successful as a brute force method of overcoming some of the game's original limitations. But for all the ways in which aims to take SimCity into the future, it remains tethered firmly to its past. Due to the peculiarities of its simulation, Origin's temperamental connection, and ultimately its own mechanical shallowness, Cities of Tomorrow is unlikely to make converts of those already driven out of town. 

6/10

Written by Graham Smith.

 

 

Login or Register
1
+1
-0
Shriven's picture
1774

Hi Graham!

1
+1
-0
Dog Pants's picture
1019

Blimey, I missed that at the bottom. Is this a special guest appearance or is Graham going to be a regular fixture?

Sorry, I have nothing to add about the review, I didn't buy SimCity. Shame though, it looks pretty and it's a new take on the franchise (isnt it?).

1
+1
-0
Acid Hoover's picture
93

I got swept up by the hyperbole, and pre-odered SimCity.

I played a few hours, but decided to hold off against playing any more once all the AI and pathfinding issues started getting reported.

And now I just can't sum up the enthusiasm to pump any more time into it.

But £25 is a joke for this. A fiver would be my limit.

Oh, and I, err, pre-ordered X Rebirth too.

I have now learned my lesson.

Alienware - Game VictoriousTurtle Beach
SimCity players in revolt after 2.0 patch leaves cities overflowing with bugs and faeces

SimCity

SimCity players in revolt after 2.0 patch leaves cities overflowing with bugs and faeces

Activision is placing copyright strikes on Call of Duty Advanced Warfare videos showing cheats and/or glitches

Activision is placing copyright strikes on Call of Duty Advanced Warfare videos showing cheats and/or glitches

All aboard the local-motive: SimCity offline mode coming today via update 10

All aboard the local-motive: SimCity offline mode coming today via update 10

Night-mayor nearly over: SimCity offline mode is just a spot of

Night-mayor nearly over: SimCity offline mode is just a spot of "final testing" away

When Bradshaw said offline SimCity required

When Bradshaw said offline SimCity required "significant engineering", she was right - Maxis

Hell procedurally freezes over: SimCity is getting an offline mode

Hell procedurally freezes over: SimCity is getting an offline mode

Lucy Bradshaw gives some

SimCity

Lucy Bradshaw gives some "straight answers" about SimCity: "In many ways, we built an MMO”

Maxis wants you to mod SimCity, but only if you play by their draconian rules

Maxis wants you to mod SimCity, but only if you play by their draconian rules

SimCity: Cities of Tomorrow comes with more maps for everyone

SimCity: Cities of Tomorrow comes with more maps for everyone

SimCity Central Train Station is a

SimCity Central Train Station is a "proof-of-concept" mod designed to herald a wave of custom buildings

Maxis

Maxis "exploring the possibility" of a SimCity offline mode, but "will not be providing bigger city sizes"

Maxis want to talk SimCity mods;

Maxis want to talk SimCity mods; "It's difficult to determine what mods cross the line"

How EA could repair SimCity's disastrous launch

SimCity

How EA could repair SimCity's disastrous launch

SimCity: Cities of Tomorrow expansion summons commercialist dystopia

SimCity: Cities of Tomorrow expansion summons commercialist dystopia

How EA are teaching SimCity players about the work of the Red Cross

How EA are teaching SimCity players about the work of the Red Cross

SimCity Mac installation problems are resolved

SimCity Mac installation problems are resolved

SimCity is out on Mac today, shares Region play with Windows

SimCity is out on Mac today, shares Region play with Windows

SimCity update 7's road bridges and tunnels should put paid to traffic problems

SimCity update 7's road bridges and tunnels should put paid to traffic problems

My first night in SimCity: the wasted time, the good time, the giant fire-breathing lizard time

Electronic Arts

My first night in SimCity: the wasted time, the good time, the giant fire-breathing lizard time

SimCity update 7 brings further improvements to traffic. No more rubbish truck clumping

SimCity update 7 brings further improvements to traffic. No more rubbish truck clumping

SimCity for Mac due for August 29 release, free for PC version owners

SimCity for Mac due for August 29 release, free for PC version owners

SimCity Update 7 introduces bridges, overpasses and tunnels for road builders

SimCity Update 7 introduces bridges, overpasses and tunnels for road builders

SimCity sells two million copies,

SimCity sells two million copies, "is a success" despite "really rough" first week

SimCity creative director leads upper-tier exodus at Maxis to start new simulation studio

SimCity creative director leads upper-tier exodus at Maxis to start new simulation studio