Michel Ancel opens up a new studio, but will stay at Ubisoft to work on Beyond Good & Evil sequel

Gotta have wraith: Shadow of Mordor's spectral powers

Seldon Crisis: a space sandbox MMO that isn't EVE Online

Team Fortress 2

Crytek CEO: “Team Fortress 2 is not a real free to play game, in a sense”

Crytek’s CEO Cervat Yerli’s been swung by free-to-play gaming, he’s pushing to have every future Crytek title run on the model - the first of which will be Warface, which Jeremy was very taken with last week. Though, Yerli’s not so keen on how Valve turned Team Fortress 2 into a free-to-play game: “Team Fortress 2 is not a real free to play game, in a sense.

“I kind of think it's a 70% free to play title. It's on the way to be there, it's a good model and it works for them, but there is still pay to win there and I don't like that.”

Valve’s version of free-to-play sees the base game being entirely free but a charge being placed on custom content. Largely this is purely cosmetic gear; the infamous hats. However, not all of it is cosmetic. There are also whole new item sets such as new weapons and apparel that apply bonuses to qualities like damage and hit points. This is what Yerli objects to “There's some great experiment there, with user-generated content, but you buy items. You have to buy items.”

In his view, “a free to play game doesn't allow you to sell items. This is the issue I have with that. We would allow communities to create items for virtual currency, but you can't really go with commercial items because that's pay to win. So that's why I'm saying I'm disapproving of the concept of Team Fortress 2, because that is effectively not quite free to play. The only thing that's free-to-play there is they I can just go into the game and play it. But there's a piece of game I can't access without spending money.”

With free-to-play being bandied about as term so much now it’s easy to forget that it’s not one single homogenous business model and that, in fact, there are very different ways of implementing it. Valve have always suggested that they’re experimenting with how to create a working model of the system so it will be interesting to see how their future games change up the system.

Login or Register
0
+0
-0
avatar

 

"We would allow communities to create items for virtual currency, but you can't really go with commercial items because that's pay to win."

I'm sure that 3D artists and contributors will really love those crytek "fun-bucks" you offer out.

I'm sure this will go down just aswell as homefront did.

Keep trying. you might hit the mark one day

0
+0
-0
avatar

So, by your logic, you won't be allowing anyone to 'buy' crytek fun-bucks with REALY money, becasue that would be commercialising the game, right?

 

Or are you just trying to softball the fact you aren't going to pay your community contributers 'real money', by villainising the way valve is so generous to it's community artists, calling it 'Play-to-win'.

 

There are only three of four item sets available in the store that give the player a 'slight' stat advantage. But purchasing is always a choice. The items are all available for free, through crafting and random item drops. If anything, it's 'pay-not-to-waste-your-time'

 

Sounds like another Exec has no idea how this industry actualy works.

0
+0
-0
avatar

You forgot to mention that along with those hat bonuses there are crippling downsides, and that crafting exists that allows you to earn those items without paying.

The whole idea was idiotic from the start, but at least Valve listened to the overwhelmingly negative response and now there only exist those 5 underpowered / sidegrade hat sets.  Thank god.

0
+0
-0
avatar

I went through the trouble of creating an account just so I could comment what a crybaby idiot this guy is. 

 

If you are comparing your unreleased game to a highly-successful game that's still very active 7 years after release, you've already lost. 

 

The game IS free to play.  I know, I've done it for years.  Crytek makes games that runlike garbage.  Nothing to see here, just a wannabe blowing smoke up his own ass.

Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
Valve believe microtransactions used for evil will ultimately

Dota 2

Valve believe microtransactions used for evil will ultimately "lose in the marketplace"

Mystery Team Fortress 2 update incoming, initiate SUSPENSE thumnnail

Mystery Team Fortress 2 update incoming, initiate SUSPENSE

[Get Ready] Super Smash Bros. Source isn't a thing, but this trailer will make you wish it was thumnnail

[Get Ready] Super Smash Bros. Source isn't a thing, but this trailer will make you wish it was

Team Fortress 2 update renders Quickplay more reliably quick and play-full thumnnail

Team Fortress 2 update renders Quickplay more reliably quick and play-full

Team Fortress 2 and Dota 2 item makers earn average of $15,000 each thumnnail

Team Fortress 2 and Dota 2 item makers earn average of $15,000 each

Steam Trading Card beta launches; achievements now have tangible value thumbmail

Portal 2

Steam Trading Card beta launches; achievements now have tangible value

Dota 2 works on Steam controller but pro play is “not really the goal” thumnnail

Dota 2 works on Steam controller but pro play is “not really the goal”

Team Fortress 2 gets frosty, big plans are in the works for 2014 thumnnail

Team Fortress 2 gets frosty, big plans are in the works for 2014

Saxxiest 2013 Team Fortress 2 Source Filmmakers announced: watch their work here thumnnail

Saxxiest 2013 Team Fortress 2 Source Filmmakers announced: watch their work here

Necromedic: healing transcends death in Team Fortress 2's Mann vs Machine Two Cities update thumnnail

Necromedic: healing transcends death in Team Fortress 2's Mann vs Machine Two Cities update

Cast your vote for the Saxxy Awards thumnnail

Cast your vote for the Saxxy Awards

What is SteamPipe? thumbmail

Team Fortress 2

What is SteamPipe?

The Mannhattan Project: Team Fortress 2 Two Cities update relocates Mann vs Machine to New York thumnnail

The Mannhattan Project: Team Fortress 2 Two Cities update relocates Mann vs Machine to New York

"We do not agree with the Attorney General’s account of the Bitcoin incident" - ESEA

Valve concoct Collector's Items, several new chemistry sets for Team Fortress 2 thumnnail

Valve concoct Collector's Items, several new chemistry sets for Team Fortress 2

Don’t give up the ghost: Team Fortress 2 update enables Halloween all year round thumnnail

Don’t give up the ghost: Team Fortress 2 update enables Halloween all year round

Scream Fortress is alive; “These updates will kill you - GUARANTEED!” thumnnail

Scream Fortress is alive; “These updates will kill you - GUARANTEED!”

Not cool: Bitcoin mining malware found in ESEA server client thumbmail

Team Fortress 2

Not cool: Bitcoin mining malware found in ESEA server client

Valve tease Team Fortress 2 Halloween event with big comic, corpse wars and spookiness thumnnail

Valve tease Team Fortress 2 Halloween event with big comic, corpse wars and spookiness

Dress as your favourite empress-killer in Team Fortress 2 thumnnail

Dress as your favourite empress-killer in Team Fortress 2

Valve bring Saxxy back for third year of TF2 video contest thumnnail

Valve bring Saxxy back for third year of TF2 video contest

Valve spook Team Fortress 2 Workshop creators into getting prepped for Halloween thumnnail

Valve spook Team Fortress 2 Workshop creators into getting prepped for Halloween

Team Fortress 2 robot figurines are quite the thing thumnnail

Team Fortress 2 robot figurines are quite the thing