Completely real: Get a first look at an Unreal Tournament map concept

Gear Up hits beta: put guns on goo or make invisible spider tanks

Free zombies: Inject some unlife into your weekend with Dead Island: Epidemic on Steam

Free to Play

Wildstar producer on the exaggerated death of subbed MMOs: "free-to-play's not a magic bullet"

Not Jeremy Gaffney.

We’ve talked a couple of times to Carbine Studios’ Jeremy Gaffney in the last few months. He’s currently promoting his promising subscription MMO, Wildstar, and on each occasion he’s made the same broad point: in the massively-multiplayer market, things are not necessarily as they seem.

“Games that look very successful in free-to-play may or may not be making profit,” he told us most recently. And then added, cryptically: “Games that look unsuccessful in subscription may actually be more profitable.”

“Different games with different business models work in a very different fashion,” he said of his new game’s chances in a bustling field. “If you look at City of Heroes [which Gaffney produced] compared to Guild Wars, it looks like City of Heroes is a smaller game. 

“And it is, fewer people play City of Heroes, they peaked out at - I don’t know the numbers - something like 200,000. But 200,000 subscribers paying $15 a month, if you do the math, that makes about as much money as selling 6 million boxes, if they last long enough.”

Gaffney cited a “couple of reasons” for Carbine’s decision to steer clear of free-to-play for Wildstar. Both lie in the “variability” of the payment model.

“There’s variability as a player because you don’t know if you’re going to get sucked in and pay $1,000 a month, because some people do. As a publisher it’s a juggling act because most the games I’ve seen end up devolving to the point that 1 or 2% of the players are paying $100 or more a month and they’re actually funding most of the free players, which can be up to 70 - 80% playing completely for free. 

“As a publisher [that variabililty] can be distracting because when you’re making money you never know when that’s going to go away. As a player it’s distracting because generally you have a very different experience if you’re playing for free - and if not, then why the hell pay?

“So free-to-play’s not a magic bullet.”

Instead, Carbine have adopted an Eve-like business model: CREDD. Players can buy CREDD items for real-world money from the developers, and trade them with a second group of players for in-game gold. This second group can then cash in their CREDD for game time and, if they’re earning enough gold, play the game for free indefinitely.

“A bunch of games have done similar systems,” said Gaffney on the system’s inspiration. “Eve’s is probably the most popular and the best known. So many people don’t know what PLEX is and so it’s tough to describe. It’s such an efficient way of taking players that want to pay a lot, who want to put extra money in the game, and then that directly funds other players game time and so it’s a lot more direct. 

“So essentially one set of players create their time, [another] use money to pay for the sub, and it’s a win-win and it pisses off gold farmers because it’s a legal source of trading gold with other players and so gets in the way of gold farmers. 

“And we like pissing off gold farmers, too.”

Hear hear. But what do you make of Gaffney's assessment of the MMO market? This is a man who's been around since Asheron's Call, so tread respectfully.

Login or Register
2
+2
-0
avatar
17

I think that the success of World of Warcraft has severely skewed people's views of how many subscribers you need to be successful in the MMO space. Depending on the size of your infrastructure and your total operating costs you can get by with much less than a few million subscribers, which seems to be what people expect all subscription MMOs to hit these days in order to be successful.

I very much look forward to playing Wildstar and I have no problem with a subscription model if I enjoy the game.

Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
Cliff Harris on Gratuitous Space Battles 2: it's a

Gratuitous Space Battles 2

Cliff Harris on Gratuitous Space Battles 2: it's a "whole new world"

Completely real: Get a first look at an Unreal Tournament map concept thumnnail

Completely real: Get a first look at an Unreal Tournament map concept

Gear Up hits beta: put guns on goo or make invisible spider tanks  thumnnail

Gear Up hits beta: put guns on goo or make invisible spider tanks

Free zombies: Inject some unlife into your weekend with Dead Island: Epidemic on Steam thumnnail

Free zombies: Inject some unlife into your weekend with Dead Island: Epidemic on Steam

What to expect from The Elder Scrolls Online's daedra-controlled Imperial City thumnnail

What to expect from The Elder Scrolls Online's daedra-controlled Imperial City

The Often-Ending Story is a trope-addled choose your own adventure thumnnail

The Often-Ending Story is a trope-addled choose your own adventure

The Last Express: Jordan Mechner remembers a different sort of war game on the centenary of its departure thumbmail

The Last Express Gold Edition

The Last Express: Jordan Mechner remembers a different sort of war game on the centenary of its departure

Aerna creators claim it's the largest and most detailed Minecraft server thumnnail

Aerna creators claim it's the largest and most detailed Minecraft server

Come in from the cold: Linux compatible games are all the rage at GOG.com thumnnail

Come in from the cold: Linux compatible games are all the rage at GOG.com

A British MP asked for in-game theft to be treated like real-world theft thumnnail

A British MP asked for in-game theft to be treated like real-world theft

Obsidian hope Pillars of Eternity sales will fund its sequel without Kickstarter thumnnail

Obsidian hope Pillars of Eternity sales will fund its sequel without Kickstarter

Respawn to introduce in-game 'black market' currency to Titanfall in Game Update 5 thumnnail

Respawn to introduce in-game 'black market' currency to Titanfall in Game Update 5

Meet IL-2: Battle of Stalingrad —the high flying return of the PC's best combat flight-sim thumbmail

IL-2: Battle of Stalingrad

Meet IL-2: Battle of Stalingrad —the high flying return of the PC's best combat flight-sim

The Sims 2 is now free on Origin, swimming pools and 18 expansions included thumnnail

The Sims 2 is now free on Origin, swimming pools and 18 expansions included

Star Wars: The Old Republic preps for largest story expansion since Rise of the Hutt Cartel thumnnail

Star Wars: The Old Republic preps for largest story expansion since Rise of the Hutt Cartel

Chat restrictions increase win rates for a

Chat restrictions increase win rates for a "large number" of League of Legends players

Well-thumbed: the Steam Controller has grown an analog stick thumnnail

Well-thumbed: the Steam Controller has grown an analog stick

The nine best Kerbal Space Program mods  thumbmail

Kerbal Space Program

The nine best Kerbal Space Program mods

Cliff Bleszinski's Project BlueStreak snatches up AAA shooter designers and staff thumnnail

Cliff Bleszinski's Project BlueStreak snatches up AAA shooter designers and staff

Tim Schafer on Double Fine publishing and not being told what to do thumnnail

Tim Schafer on Double Fine publishing and not being told what to do

Get back in The Room when it comes to PC on July 28th thumnnail

Get back in The Room when it comes to PC on July 28th

The Humble Square Enix Bundle throws Hitman, Thief and even Anachronox at you thumnnail

The Humble Square Enix Bundle throws Hitman, Thief and even Anachronox at you

God Squad: Lara Croft and the Temple of Osiris due out in December thumnnail

God Squad: Lara Croft and the Temple of Osiris due out in December