Prison Architect's alpha 23 update adds remote access systems and floods prisons with contraband

Michel Ancel opens up a new studio, but will stay at Ubisoft to work on Beyond Good & Evil sequel

Gotta have wraith: Shadow of Mordor's spectral powers

Magic 2014 — Duels of the Planeswalkers

Wizards of the Coast are suing Cryptozoic: "Hex is a nearly identical game to Magic"

Hex: Shards of Fate is a really excellent CCG. That, at least, is not under dispute.

Blatant, willful, and malicious. That’s what Wizards of the Coast think of Cryptozoic’s work on the digital card game Hex. They believe the CCG developers have misappropriated enough particulars of Magic: The Gathering to fill several pages of a patent infringement suit.

“In short, Cryptozoic has produced a nearly identical copy of Magic,” wrote the publishers in their claim.

In March, Wizards contacted Cryptozoic to let them know their opinions on Hex - but despite “earnest negotiations”, the two companies reached an “impasse”.

Now, Wizards of the Coast are looking for a “permanent injunction” restricting Cryptozoic from continuing to appropriate their IP, as they see it. What’s more, they want the cash Cryptozoic have so far made via Hex, which they estimate exceeds $500,000.

The Wizards say Hex not only retains the “look and feel” of Magic, but many of its “mechanics, plot, actions and elements” - which in several cases feature the same names.

Wizards of the Coast say they recognise their own scoring system in Hex, “distinctive Magic playing pieces”, and even an “identical” sequence and flow in the way it is played.

The claim goes into granular detail about the similarities between the two games - placing specific cards side-by-side to demonstrate, and quoting fan podcasts in an attempt to show that players were “confused” about the relationship between the two games.

Wizards of the Coast say that Hex’s visual design is “misleading” enough to suggest a “false association” with Magic - and believe that Cryptozoic are “knowingly and intentionally” attempting to “trade off the goodwill that Wizards has developed”.

“Hex is a nearly identical game,” reads the suit. “Cryptozoic both had access to and had copied Magic.”

Our Jules called Hex a truly brilliant computer CCG - the second time it's been called that on this site. That, at least, is not under dispute. Let's hope we don't lose it.

Login or Register
1
+1
-0
toomer34's picture
4

To be fair, reading from the suit it was clear that wizards of the coast do in fact have a legitimate claim, of IP, over the mechanics they dispute were stolen from their game. Having not played Hex or seen videos of it's game play I can't say for sure that it's an exact clone but from what I read they do have an astonishing amount of similarities between the card mechanics as well as gameplay and progression.

So far Wizards have thus made a perfectly reasonable argument that their IP was adopted without a reasonable amount of separation and no compensation. I was willing to give Hex the benefit of the doubt thinking that it was just genre wars but honestly there is a line when it comes to creative IP and their reuse and Hex is definitely in the dangerzone.

1
+1
-0
Gwathdring's picture
75

Having not seen it played or played it you ought not take WotC's word for it. A good legal brief out to be very, very one-sided. That's kinda the point.

1
+1
-0
Gwathdring's picture
75

This worries me. There are so many card games that rely on so many similar mechanics and so many Magic the Gathering players for whom what were once proprietary terms have now become basic gaming parlance (not to mention all the terms Magic uses that are just ... *obvious* and not in any way claimable such as Instant, half of the ability/trait names, and the use of colors to differentiate between various different kinds of card currencies, the word Mana).

That they have the absolute gall to say the *plot* is the same is hilarious. The number of games about spellcasters and summoners dueling is ... staggering.

My main worry is that their claiming proprietary access to some basic answers to the question "what kinds of special abilities can my cards have?" in this sort of deck-based dueling game. In other words, they're essentially claiming the right to deck-based summoner duel card games. That seem ... wrong. As a game designer that bothers me. It would be like Activision and EA getting into a legal fracas over CoD and Battlefield, citing things like weapon unlocks, capture the flag, death match, elements of the gunplay, etc. Or generic FPS #1 accusing generic FPS #2 of having escort missions, horde-defense missions, linear levels, and so forth. It's crass and it's a gross misunderstanding of what Magic The Gathering is. It's ancient and massive as hell and it's also utterly generic--it has done pretty much everything you can do with cards simply by virtue of existing for an eon and a half. By wielding copyright it's trying to claim ownership of an entire sub-genre.

I think Cryptozoic was very, very foolish though in some of their aesthetic and trivial choices. There are some small changes they could have made without altering the play of the game to help protect themselves form this kind of thing (gaining victory points from dealing damage that goes unblocked, for example). So I'm in the odd position of not feeling very sorry for them at all, but not feeling WotC is right either.

If anything Cryptozoic put WotC in a tight spot. While I don't agree this is in bad-faith or that it's similar enough to merit infringement ... WotC has to be worried about the precedent this will set for the future of their game and future potential infringement cases. So WotC isn't necessarily acting in bad-faith EITHER.

Alienware - Game VictoriousNvidia Shield - Titanfall
IL-2 and Rise of Flight producer on making modern flight sims thumbmail

Ilya Muromets

IL-2 and Rise of Flight producer on making modern flight sims

Prison Architect's alpha 23 update adds remote access systems and floods prisons with contraband thumnnail

Prison Architect's alpha 23 update adds remote access systems and floods prisons with contraband

Michel Ancel opens up a new studio, but will stay at Ubisoft to work on Beyond Good & Evil sequel thumnnail

Michel Ancel opens up a new studio, but will stay at Ubisoft to work on Beyond Good & Evil sequel

Gotta have wraith: Shadow of Mordor's spectral powers  thumnnail

Gotta have wraith: Shadow of Mordor's spectral powers

Seldon Crisis: a space sandbox MMO that isn't EVE Online thumnnail

Seldon Crisis: a space sandbox MMO that isn't EVE Online

Evolve alpha: three days of stalking begins tomorrow thumnnail

Evolve alpha: three days of stalking begins tomorrow

Pillars of Eternity preview:

Pillars of Eternity

Pillars of Eternity preview: "This is supposed to be the dream game for people who like Infinity Engine games"

Gearbox attempts to get removed from Aliens: Colonial Marines class action lawsuit thumnnail

Gearbox attempts to get removed from Aliens: Colonial Marines class action lawsuit

Master Path of Exile in the free expansion, Forsaken Masters thumnnail

Master Path of Exile in the free expansion, Forsaken Masters

Wildstar's 'Sabotage' update makes PvP super explosive, introduces bomb chucking fun thumnnail

Wildstar's 'Sabotage' update makes PvP super explosive, introduces bomb chucking fun

A time before Steam: an ode to the budget boxed PC game thumbmail

Mastertronic

A time before Steam: an ode to the budget boxed PC game

Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn begins its free two-week trial thumnnail

Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn begins its free two-week trial

F1 2014 is announced, features shiniest cars and wettest roads ever thumnnail

F1 2014 is announced, features shiniest cars and wettest roads ever

Mastertronic lay off staff, leave boxed games behind:

Mastertronic lay off staff, leave boxed games behind: "PC budget games now sold online"

The Sims 4 does anger, sadness, embarrassment: all the classics thumnnail

The Sims 4 does anger, sadness, embarrassment: all the classics

Minecraft snapshot 14w31a reworks the world border, adds noisier rabbits thumnnail

Minecraft snapshot 14w31a reworks the world border, adds noisier rabbits

Topic of the Week: What do you want from the new Mass Effect? thumbmail

Mass Effect 4

Topic of the Week: What do you want from the new Mass Effect?

Looking for love among the pigeons: Hatoful Boyfriend launches on August 21st thumnnail

Looking for love among the pigeons: Hatoful Boyfriend launches on August 21st

Hacker holiday: Watch Dogs leaves Chicago and visits Camden, New Jersey in new DLC thumnnail

Hacker holiday: Watch Dogs leaves Chicago and visits Camden, New Jersey in new DLC

Strange bedfellows: YouPorn has found an eSports team to sponsor thumnnail

Strange bedfellows: YouPorn has found an eSports team to sponsor

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare has three collector's editions for you to choose from thumnnail

Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare has three collector's editions for you to choose from

World of Tanks 9.2 introduces clan strongholds and a new map for dastardly snipers  thumnnail

World of Tanks 9.2 introduces clan strongholds and a new map for dastardly snipers