Battlefield 4 Multiplayer Hands-On | PCGamesN

The 101 Best Free PC Games

Reign of Kings Early Access review

Oculus VR's chief scientist is a big fan of The Matrix and that's scary for many reasons

Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4 Multiplayer Hands-On

Before they would let us play EA’s wildly impressive 64-player Battlefield 4 set-up on PC, we watched a video demonstrating what could be seen as “optimum play” for the level we were all about to try — Siege of Shanghai, definitely the most ambitious scenario that DICE have attempted yet. 

With the US facing off against China for control of a series of control points across a massive map — including one vital point on the top of a wobbly skyscraper — the entire thing looked bloody amazing. Huge battles across the map. A player trapped underground who destroys a load bearing pillar that disables a tank sitting on the road above. Commandos parachuting from the top of the skyscraper right before the entire thing came down, changing the battlefield completely.

It was an amazing demonstration of possibility. And it completely ruined the reality of playing Battlefield 4.

In retrospect, that video of Battlefield 4 at its imagined best was probably not the perfect set-up for subsequently enjoying E3 gameplay with a group of players who could be considered a completely disorganized, hopelessly confused bunch of lunatics. I’d hoped for a rag-tag bunch of go-getters, and I got a group who were quite happy to spend most of their time trying to work out how to do a three-point turn with a tank in a small alley rather than, you know, do anything useful with it.

So, it’s immediately apparent that despite the valuable re-introduction of the commander, who is intended to guide and support on-the-ground troops with everything from waypoints to missile strikes, Battlefield 4 isn’t going to solve the poor quality of pickup games.

Worse than that, however, for all of Siege of Shanghai’s astonishing pyrotechnics when played optimally, in my entire game I never saw anything that interesting happen. Even with the full set of 64 players, Siege of Shanghai just felt too large. Weird, blustery and often empty, if I managed to run to a control point and get involved in a little back and forth combat (usually, and unfortunately, at a distance), the moment I died, I was in for a tiresome hike from the spawn point. With less than 64 players, God knows how empty it’ll feel.

That’s not to say Battlefield 4 feels like a total failure, however. Shanghai was still stunningly realistic running on the mega PCs that EA were packing. The sound design was incredible (and it was competing with the non-stop white noise of E3, too.) And the team are clearly doing things to try and mitigate some of the more obvious problems: if you follow your commanders commands, you’ll receive bonus experience, for example. That kind of thing won’t really pay off until the full multiplayer experience is on offer. The problem is that when you really get down to it, it all feels pretty much like Battlefield 3.

So if Battlefield 4 is shaping up to be Battlefield 3, only “bigger” and “more”, is it really what we need or deserve right now? Siege of Shanghai might only one level, but it has that worrying sense of offering that clichéd “EA update” that serves no one but the bottom line. Unless, of course, you’ve got your heart set on playing the commander, which does offer something genuinely different indeed (especially for those with a touch-screen PC.) 

But for the troops? Well, war never changes, eh?

Login or Register
-1
+0
-1
avatar

Hey this isn't call of duty when all you do is run around in tight maps dying every 3 seconds. DICE is trying to bring back more teamwork features and larger maps, Battlefield 3 is what ruined the series. 

 

If you want a mash of clusterfuck, go play CoD. 

Try these free to play games
?

These are affiliate links - clicking them and playing the games directly supports PCGamesN

Spotlight
?

Our Spotlight units plug content our journalists have made, that our advertisers want to promote. Sometimes the promotion is paid for, but the content they go to is always independent with no client oversight or approval.


Alienware - Game VictoriousTurtle Beach
The Trial of Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4

The Trial of Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4 Winter Update brings about

Battlefield 4 Winter Update brings about "more exact" man-shooting via netcode upgrade

Make a map with DICE in Battlefield 4

Make a map with DICE in Battlefield 4

The Battlefield 4 kraken is dead, Paracel Storm easter egg is no more

The Battlefield 4 kraken is dead, Paracel Storm easter egg is no more

DICE on Battlefield 4’s future: “Final Stand is not the end”

DICE on Battlefield 4’s future: “Final Stand is not the end”

Battlefield 4's Final Stand now being stood by premium players, trailered for the rest of us

Battlefield 4's Final Stand now being stood by premium players, trailered for the rest of us

AMD's Mantle API: how it works and why PC developers will adopt it

Battlefield 4

AMD's Mantle API: how it works and why PC developers will adopt it

Battlefield 4's war concludes with Final Stand on November 18th

Battlefield 4's war concludes with Final Stand on November 18th

Final Stand DLC will bring bows to Battlefield 4 with explosive and sniper bolts, say dataminers

Final Stand DLC will bring bows to Battlefield 4 with explosive and sniper bolts, say dataminers

DICE open up Battlefield 4 PC test servers to premium console players

DICE open up Battlefield 4 PC test servers to premium console players

Judge dismisses securities fraud suit against EA; executives were just being optimistic

Judge dismisses securities fraud suit against EA; executives were just being optimistic

Battlefield 4: Final Stand now available on Community Test Environment

Battlefield 4: Final Stand now available on Community Test Environment

Some things Battlefield 4 has taught me about war

Battlefield 4

Some things Battlefield 4 has taught me about war

DICE:

DICE: "we lost player trust" because of Battlefield 4 launch

The big, fat Battlefield 4 Premium Edition is only a fortnight away

The big, fat Battlefield 4 Premium Edition is only a fortnight away

Before the Fall Patch: long-awaited Battlefield 4 fixes due today on Origin

Before the Fall Patch: long-awaited Battlefield 4 fixes due today on Origin

Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4 "Autumn Patch" sheds all the bugs; further improves netcode

Battlefield 4: Final Stand evokes memories of Battlefield 2142

Battlefield 4: Final Stand evokes memories of Battlefield 2142

The Battlefield 4 launch is just another high profile cock up

Battlefield 4

The Battlefield 4 launch is just another high profile cock up

Battlefield 4's September patch to emulate Battlefield 3's soldier movement

Battlefield 4's September patch to emulate Battlefield 3's soldier movement

War is cheap in Battlefield 4: it's free for a week and on sale

War is cheap in Battlefield 4: it's free for a week and on sale

EA hire eBay exec as their new CTO to help improve their games

EA hire eBay exec as their new CTO to help improve their games "as live services"

Watch 30 seconds of Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth before its Premium launch tomorrow

Watch 30 seconds of Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth before its Premium launch tomorrow

Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth is definitely coming out on July 15th; no take backs this time

Battlefield 4: Dragon's Teeth is definitely coming out on July 15th; no take backs this time