Papa John's runs eSports promotion, but gets mixed reception | PCGamesN

Papa John's runs eSports promotion, but gets mixed reception

What he lacks in civic generosity, "Papa" John Schnatter makes up for with garlic butter.

Papa John’s are offering eSports fans 50% off if they order using the promo code “PIZZAGG”, and major eSports organizations like Evil Geniuses, Team Liquid, Onemoregame.tv, and ROOT Gaming are all participating in the chain’s eSports initiative. It’s clearly a significant moment for eSports, since Papa John’s is a massive pizza chain and exactly the kind of mainstream brand that many eSports stakeholders want to attract. Over on TeamLiquid, a statement from EG, Liquid, and ROOT suggests, “If you feel like eating a pizza (or two or three or ten) this week, please consider using Papa John’s and help us show them what we can do!”

The reaction from other members of the eSports community, however, has not been quite as universally enthusiastic. What’s interesting is that the objections aren’t about “selling out” or the highly debatable quality of Papa John’s pizza, but about values. It’s a debate that may have ramifications for how eSports culture differs from that of traditional mass-entertainment.

Papa John’s CEO John Schnatter was an outspoken opponent of the controversial Affordable Care Act, which aims to extend healthcare to previous uninsured Americans and reduce overall healthcare costs. In public statements, he explained the law would raise his costs for doing business and that he would find ways to keep from having to insure Papa John’s employees (like cutting hours).

The funny thing is that a lot of people in eSports actually remember this, and are still turned-off by it. John “TotalBiscuit” Bain was quite pointed in his criticism of the sponsor.

 

 

 

 

 

 

You could find some of these same points in the thread over at Team Liquid, and other people working in eSports raised similar concerns. LoLKing.net Community Director Rhea “Ashelia” Monique called the company “scum” for how they treated the issue of healthcare for their employees.

Now the US healthcare battle is a bruising and ugly one, but what I find interesting about the reception Papa John’s is getting in eSports is the way people are judging the company by its stated values and behavior as a corporate citizen.

Marketing in traditional sports is often about faking a consensus. Beer ads are celebrations of an increasingly antique view of masculinity and culture, but they are trying to sell cheap lager as a rejection of complexity. Papa John’s just wants to be what you think when you’re trying to have a party around a sporting event.

What’s striking here is that a lot of people in eSports are explicitly rejecting the notion that there is a division between business and politics, or entertainment and values. While there are surely a ton of eSports fans who ordering pizza tonight to show their love of the game and appreciation of Papa John’s support, it’s striking to see so many people raising the question of whether you can or should separate what a company’s executives believe from the decision to order a pizza and enjoy some eSports. It’s a small thing, but a marked difference from the passive consumerism that characterizes traditional sports.

Login or Register
Try these free to play games
?

These are affiliate links - clicking them and playing the games directly supports PCGamesN

Spotlight
?

Our Spotlight units plug content our journalists have made, that our advertisers want to promote. Sometimes the promotion is paid for, but the content they go to is always independent with no client oversight or approval.

Alienware - Game VictoriousTurtle Beach
Blizzard announces Whispers of Oblivion, a free mission series for StarCraft 2

Starcraft II

Blizzard announces Whispers of Oblivion, a free mission series for StarCraft 2

It's the Starcraft II WCS finals today; watch the quarterfinals underway right now

It's the Starcraft II WCS finals today; watch the quarterfinals underway right now

Get clued-up on the StarCraft II: Legacy of the Void closed beta, launching this month

Get clued-up on the StarCraft II: Legacy of the Void closed beta, launching this month

NetEase and Blizzard launch new StarCraft 2 league, Gold Series Pro League, to replace WCS Challenger

NetEase and Blizzard launch new StarCraft 2 league, Gold Series Pro League, to replace WCS Challenger

Blizzard slow down Starcraft II combat pace as an experiment; more testing before

Blizzard slow down Starcraft II combat pace as an experiment; more testing before "final call"

More allegations of match-fixing and illegal betting activity in pro StarCraft

More allegations of match-fixing and illegal betting activity in pro StarCraft

Accusations of StarCraft match-fixing against progamer San from betting site Pinnacle

Starcraft II

Accusations of StarCraft match-fixing against progamer San from betting site Pinnacle

Big changes to StarCraft's Swarm Host in upcoming Balance Test Map

Big changes to StarCraft's Swarm Host in upcoming Balance Test Map

Watch a StarCraft: Brood War tournament for student-made bots

Watch a StarCraft: Brood War tournament for student-made bots

How Starcraft 2: Legacy of the Void makes your Protoss fantasies come true

How Starcraft 2: Legacy of the Void makes your Protoss fantasies come true

Here's all the new multiplayer units coming to Starcraft 2: Legacy of the Void

Here's all the new multiplayer units coming to Starcraft 2: Legacy of the Void

Starcraft 2's final chapter, Legacy of the Void, is a standalone expansion

Starcraft 2's final chapter, Legacy of the Void, is a standalone expansion

The 2015 WCS StarCraft 2 season begins, but is it too much of a good thing?

Starcraft II

The 2015 WCS StarCraft 2 season begins, but is it too much of a good thing?

Final StarCraft II sound clip teases BlizzCon announcement, possibly Legacy of the Void

Final StarCraft II sound clip teases BlizzCon announcement, possibly Legacy of the Void

Blizzard tease cryptic Starcraft II sound clips; possible announcement at BlizzCon

Blizzard tease cryptic Starcraft II sound clips; possible announcement at BlizzCon

Radical changes for WCS StarCraft in 2015 — the full rundown

Radical changes for WCS StarCraft in 2015 — the full rundown

WCS StarCraft 2 Global Finals round of 16 starting now

WCS StarCraft 2 Global Finals round of 16 starting now

The Red Bull Battle Grounds Grand Final invades Washington D.C.

The Red Bull Battle Grounds Grand Final invades Washington D.C.

Why pro StarCraft 2 has rejected the classic maps

Starcraft II

Why pro StarCraft 2 has rejected the classic maps

Last chance to make the finals: Red Bull Battle Grounds Detroit has begun

Last chance to make the finals: Red Bull Battle Grounds Detroit has begun

Spend the weekend watching Red Bull Battle Grounds Atlanta right here

Spend the weekend watching Red Bull Battle Grounds Atlanta right here

eSports Titanics and financial icebergs - What ESGN's problems mean for eSport

eSports Titanics and financial icebergs - What ESGN's problems mean for eSport

Back to terra with a thump: Blizzard sue

Back to terra with a thump: Blizzard sue "insidious and harmful" StarCraft 2 cheat devs

Blizzard's sorting out your friends list in the latest Starcraft 2 patch

Blizzard's sorting out your friends list in the latest Starcraft 2 patch