We may earn a commission when you buy through links in our articles. Learn more.

Rainbow Six Extraction review - dead ringer

Ubisoft's Siege spinoff fails to develop the PvE mode that inspired it four years ago

Smoke readying up for an incursion in our Rainbow Six Extraction review

Our Verdict

Ubisoft's PvE shooter fails to extract the best out of Rainbow Six Siege's gameplay mechanics, and the result is a repetitive, mostly bland co-op assignment.

Rainbow Six Extraction is a square peg in a round hole. It shares most of its DNA with one of the last decade’s best multiplayer games, the asymmetric tactical shooter Rainbow Six Siege. All of Extraction’s playable characters come directly from Siege’s roster, with similar loadouts and only minor revisions to the functionality of each operator’s gadget. It also adopts Siege’s destructible environments, so you can shred most walls back to their studs with the right gadgets or enough bullets. Extraction even continues the sci-fi narrative that Siege started back in 2018 with the limited-time PvE event, Outbreak.

All of those ingredients are present in Extraction, but they’ve been mixed in such a way that they fail to impart any flavour. Destruction works exactly as it does in Siege, but there’s no benefit to opening new pathways, and no way to exploit breachable surfaces thanks to the predominantly horizontal map design. Some operators have been creatively reworked to suit the new horde threat, but others seem out of place and ill-equipped. With so many of its components carried over verbatim from Siege, Extraction feels as much like a limited-time game mode as Outbreak did.

The story picks up shortly after the events of Outbreak, with its alien parasites – dubbed Archæans – springing up all over North America and evolving to pose a greater challenge for team Rainbow. You start on Liberty Island in New York City, travel west to San Francisco, north to Alaska, and finally south to New Mexico. There are three maps to choose from in each location, but it doesn’t really matter which one you’re playing on as the objectives you’ll need to complete are randomly assigned when you start a match.

Each objective is located in its own third of the map, and there’s a Left 4 Dead-like safe zone between each area with a stock of ammo, reinforcements, and health kits to share around. As the title suggests, extraction is a key part of the game, and you’ll always have the choice of heading to an extraction point to safely escape halfway through an incursion, rather than pushing on to the next sub-zone with a sliver of health and risk wiping.

Approaching a singularity in our Rainbow Six Extraction review

And that’s a risk you really don’t want to take. When your operator is knocked out they’ll go into stasis and get captured by the parasite. If this happens, not only do you lose all the XP you earned during that run, your operator also loses some individual progress and you’re forced to rescue them in your next incursion.

While each sub-zone draws from a pool of 13 potential objectives, they rarely require you to tailor your approach. There are stealthy objectives that task you with sneaking around to plant tracking devices in nests, or perform stealth takedowns on elite enemies. Escort missions come in three different flavours: escort a parasite-killing bomb, escort a downed researcher, or escort a downed teammate. Sometimes you’ll need to kill an elite enemy, other times you’ll need to bait it into an incapacitating trap. There are objectives in which you’ll need to find and activate three computers in the right sequence while a timer ticks away (this one’s easy if you just clear out most of the sub-zone before touching the first computer).

None of these require you to make use of your operator’s gadget or consider the map’s destructibility. There are a couple of minor exceptions that charge you with defending an objective for a minute or two, which you’ll do by placing down reinforcements, barricades, and gadgets to direct the flow of incoming Archæans. You have some scope for creating tactical setups during these missions, especially if you use shotguns to open up long lines of sight, but as certain enemies can breach both soft and reinforced walls alike, there’s really no way to control which direction they’ll flood in from.

Alibi using her Prisma against the parasite in our Rainbow Six Extraction review

Operator gadgets are a little more impactful. Siege’s stalwart, Tachanka, still sports his Soviet-era deployable LMG and is devastatingly effective during those defensive objectives. However, other operators have had their signature gadgets tweaked just enough to prove effective against the parasite, but no more. For the most part they feel the same, which reinforces the disappointing sense of deja vu that pervades Extraction. Vigil, for example, can now cloak himself from Archæans, letting you slink away after kicking the proverbial hornet’s nest. Alibi’s Prisma holograms pull aggro away from your squad, not only giving everyone a breather, but also making it much easier to focus your fire at a miniboss. Even Jäger’s grenade-catching gadget has been tweaked so it fires a deadly shot at any Archæan that comes into range – very handy for locking down a room.

PC Game Pass PC Game Pass PC Game Pass Microsoft $9.99 $1.00 Buy now Network N earns commission from qualifying purchases via Microsoft and other programs.

But for every reworked operator you’ll find one who offers almost nothing to your squad. Fuze’s cluster charges are less effective than simply shooting through a wall with a suppressed weapon, and while you can create traps with them by luring Archæans towards them, there’s no need to create such an elaborate scenario. IQ can ping supplies through walls with her scanner, but the range isn’t sufficient to reveal anything that you can’t find just by looking a bit more carefully. And Rook? Well, Rook can pass around armour plates just like in Siege, which prevent instant knockouts and grant a minor buff to your damage resistance, but it’s probably the most boring ‘ability’ in the history of hero shooters.

Some operators become extremely powerful once you level them up, with raw stat boosts, new weapons, additional gadget uses, and even new gadget functionalities unlocked at max level. Put in the work and Tachanka can deploy two turrets simultaneously, so another teammate can get mounted and loaded. Reaching an operator’s level cap takes a dozen or so complete and successful incursions, and this can be a real slog for some of the initially weak characters.

Shooting a grunt in our Rainbow Six Extraction review

The Archæans themselves come in a few different varieties, but only a couple demand any sort of coordination à la Left 4 Dead 2’s Witch or Jockey. The heavily armoured Smasher is downright lethal head-on, but if you can stun it or get a teammate to flank, then its weak spot is easy enough to get at. Likewise, the Apex, which can summon fellow Archæans at an alarming rate, just needs a few seconds of focused fire to dispatch.

The real threat in Extraction comes from the Sprawl, a viscous black goop that seeps and spreads across the map, slowing your movement whenever you walk through it. Sprawl oozes from any Archæans you mow down as well as from nests you disturb, so you’ll encounter a lot more of it if you take a reckless approach.

Extraction is full of mechanics that punish you for going in guns blazing. Disturbed nests will start spitting out new Archæan soldiers, and any Archæan that spots you can release a shriek to rally every ally in the area. As more enemies come flooding in, so does more Sprawl, and very quickly it becomes difficult to make any forward progress. The chain reaction that turns a mission from smooth sailing to helter-skelter is almost instantaneous, so it really does feel like there’s only one way to approach Extraction if you want to survive. But that method is quite tedious. Crouch-walking through corridors, carefully scanning each room for Archæans, and destroying nests is easy, but it’s time-consuming, and doesn’t evolve much even as the difficulty scales.

Exploring a biker bar in our Rainbow Six Extraction review

And that’s pretty much Extraction. You cycle between 12 maps and a few different objective types, leveling up your operators and increasing the difficulty setting to earn more XP. Tracks of optional challenges offer lore titbits and extra rewards, but frustratingly they’re map-specific and can only be completed one set at a time. I played one map three times in a row hoping for a specific enemy type, completed the last challenge of the set, and then had to extract and start again to access the next set of tasks. The reward? Two sentences about a miniscule development in the team’s research efforts and some XP.

While the random selection of objectives for each sub-zone does make every playthrough a little different, it ultimately limits the stakes. It’s impossible to emulate the nail-biting tension of Left 4 Dead or Back 4 Blood’s carefully curated set pieces with small map areas and randomised objectives, and I find myself missing the scale of these climaxes.

The closest Extraction gets is with its Singularity objective type, in which your team takes on one of three Proteans. These are proper boss fights against an Archæan mimic of either Smoke, Alibi, or Sledge, each with their own alien twist on their counterpart’s gadget. Alibi, for example, casts multiple clones so she’s hard to track across the arena, while Smoke leaves a trail of toxic fumes wherever he goes, restricting your movement and vision.

Moving between sub-zones in our Rainbow Six Extraction review

Maps make poor use of their regional settings. You’ll clear out New York high rises without any cityscape views to make you pick up your jaw from the floor, and a biker bar in San Francisco’s Tenderloin neighbourhood could be set anywhere else in the world. Worse still, the only form of narrative development comes through short, ultimately pointless CGI cinematics you unlock with each new region. In one, Eliza ‘Ash’ Cohen spends half a minute building up the next location, and then it just ends. No story development, no greater sense of her emotional state, how the team’s holding up, or if the threat’s escalating.

After a ten or so hours repeating the same objectives across the different maps you’ll gain access to Extraction’s two endgame modes: Wall-to-Wall and Maelstrom Protocol. Disappointingly, these are basically longer, more challenging versions of the core mission structure. Wall-to-Wall introduces a horde-like threat, with Archæans constantly spawning in and rushing your squad.

Maelstrom Protocol is just three back-to-back incursions with the difficulty turned up to eleven. The map, objectives, and enemy modifiers change every week, creating a gruelling gauntlet that players can learn and master through multiple attempts. It’s repetitive, sure, but I’ve enjoyed Maelstrom Protocol more than any other part of Extraction. Identifying the fastest, cleanest route to the objective and executing your plan to perfection is hugely satisfying, and it provides a sense of growth that’s absent in Extraction’s other modes. After a dozen or so attempts I’ve still not made it all the way through, but by making tiny adjustments to my loadout and how I deploy my limited gadgets I’m making steady progress.

Extracting a sample from a nest in Rainbow Six Extraction

The journey to endgame has been dreary, with nowhere near enough tension and variety to break up the monotony of Extraction’s repeating objective types. It’s ironic then, that a mode that’s even more repetitive should provide some silver lining. But Maelstrom Protocol feels like it has a shelf life, too, and the sort of satisfaction it provides is closer to that of working away at a Rubik’s Cube than the thrill of a tightly choreographed horde shooter or a tense sweep-and-clear mission.

Ultimately, there’s only so far wrong Ubisoft could have gone with Extraction, because it’s built on the robust skeleton of Siege. The gunplay, weapon design, and sound design are great, but they’re all mostly carried over from another game, and that shows in the weapon balancing, which mirrors Siege in nonsensical, frustrating ways – is it really necessary for Rook’s P90 to deal almost no damage and kick like a mule in a PvE game?

On a purely technical level, Extraction works. It feels good to play in a dry, mechanical sort of way, but it’s rarely very fun or exciting.

PC Game Pass PC Game Pass PC Game Pass Microsoft $9.99 $1.00 Buy now Network N earns commission from qualifying purchases via Microsoft and other programs.