Disney Dreamlight Valley Mystical Cave riddles and solutions

Solve the Disney Dreamlight Valley Mystical Cave riddles and reach the Power Orb at the bottom to free Dazzle Beach from the dark magic trapping its residents

Disney Dreamlight Valley Mystical Cave: A blonde, female player character stands in front of the stony entrance to the Mystical cave

The Disney Dreamlight Valley Mystical Cave is an important stop on your way to overcoming The Forgetting and saving the valley, so you’ll need to know how to solve the riddles within.

One of the best PC games released last year, Dreamlight Valley is a story-driven game, encompassing aspects of life sims, farming games, and more, similar to games like Animal Crossing. Being Disney though, there’s a strong emphasis on friendship, courage, and even power, and that’s where the Mystical Cave comes in. If you’re in the early stages of the Disney game, you might find our Dreamlight Valley beginner’s guide useful to get you started. Among your very first challenges though, Merlin will help you unlock Dazzle Beach. Having gained access to the biome, your first stop is a small cursed cave in which Ursula is trapped, and you must venture into the Mystical Cave to free her.

Disney Dreamlight Valley Mystical Cave gem riddle: Text reads "Provide the gen that matches to continue on your hero's quest"

How to solve all Dreamlight Valley Mystical Cave riddles

As you descend the cave, you’ll come across a series of locked doors with statues around. In the middle of each set of statues is a riddle. You must find the correct items to give to the statues, in order to unlock the next door. Here are all of the riddles and what you need to do to complete them:

Mystical Cave gem riddle

“Provide the gem that matches best to continue on your hero’s quest.”

All you need to do here is give a gem to each of the stone statues, making sure the colour of the gemstone correctly matches that on the statue’s chest. With one green, one blue, and one red statue, you need to collect a Peridot, Aquamarine, and Garnet, respectively.

These gems appear in rock formations in walls around the Valley, which can be broken using your magic pickaxe. Some will be obvious, as you’ll be able to see the coloured gem in the rock itself, but don’t let this fool you – gems can drop from any of these large rock deposits, so be sure to break them all. The specific locations you’ll need for these three, though, are:

  • Peridot – Dazzle Beach or Peaceful Meadow.
  • Aquamarine – Dazzle Beach.
  • Garnet – Peaceful Meadow or The Plaza.

Once you have one of each gem, return to the Mystical Cave and offer the correct one to each statue, and you can continue your path to the next puzzle.

Disney Dreamlight Valley Mystical Cave Crop riddle: Text reads "Discover the right crops to grow to continue on below"

Mystical Cave crop riddle

“Discover the right crops to grow, to continue on below. One is underground, the other gold and brown. What remains is red and round.”

Descend further into the cave and you’ll find another riddle. This is slightly more complex than the first, as you need to decipher and find the correct seeds, plant them, and wait for them to grow before the door will open. The seeds you need are:

  • “Underground” – Carrot
  • “Gold and Brown” – Wheat
  • “Red and round” – Tomato

You should have plenty of carrot seeds, as they can be obtained from destroying Night Thorns, but all three can be purchased from Goofy at one of his stands. You need to complete some of Scrooge McDuck’s quests to open Goofy’s stands, and carrot and wheat seeds can both be purchased from his Peaceful Meadow stall. If you are struggling to find tomato seeds, it might be because you need to unlock Goofy’s stand on Dazzle Beach first. You may even need to upgrade it a couple of times before tomato seeds are available to buy.

When you have all three seed types, head back into the Mystical Cave, plant the seeds in front of the stone statues in any order, water them, and wait for them to grow. You must wait 25 minutes before the tomatoes are fully grown, but as soon as they are, the next door will open.

Disney Dreamlight Valley Mystical Cave cooking riddle: a blonde, female player character stands next to a cooking pot

Mystical Cave cooking riddle

“The final riddle, let it be known: To cook and eat what you have grown.”

The third and final Mystical Cave riddle is much shorter, and far less complex. You essentially just have to cook the three crops from before. Unless you have spares to hand, simply harvest your crops from the previous area to ensure you have the ingredients you need. There is a stove in the cave, so you can go ahead and simply place the carrot, wheat and tomato in the pot, along with a piece of coal ore. If you don’t have this, it can be obtained from breaking rocks anywhere in the Valley.

The three ingredients result in the three-star Veggie Pasta meal, and while you don’t need the recipe to cook it, it can be found – along with some other treasures – hidden in this area of the cave. Simply dig the sand with your magic shovel and break the rocks with your pickaxe.

As per the riddle, you must also eat your meal to continue, so chow down and the final door will open. To eat the meal, press I to open your inventory, select the item, and click “Eat”, restoring your energy in the process.

Get the Orb of Power in Disney Dreamlight Valley

How to get the Power Orb

At the very bottom of the Mystical Cave, you can finally obtain the Power Orb. This is glowing in the cave’s waters, so just pull out your magic Fishing Rod and hook the item out. Take it to the surface, interact with the Dazzle Beach pillar, and release the shoreline from the grip of dark magic – you’ll soon see Ursula hopping between the Valley’s ponds and seas.

Game Pass for PC Game Pass for PC Game Pass for PC Microsoft $9.99 $1 (first month) Subscribe Network N earns commission from qualifying purchases via Microsoft and other programs.

Now you can obtain the Power Orb, you are well on your way to unlocking more biomes, as well as the Dreamlight Valley Scar quests. There, there are new items to discover, like Dreamlight Valley clay and seaweed. When your inventory is full, find out how to upgrade your house in Disney Dreamlight Valley to get more space for all your discoveries, and the fun things you make with them.